Wednesday, December 07, 2022

Tom Emmer and the Blockchain Caucus. Wanting the SEC to cut a little slack, to lessen things, by letter back a few months to the SEC Chair, for more breathing space for crypto promoters.

They can't breathe? Heavy knee of regulation on their necks?

Now, from one perhaps more a cynic - skeptic than Crabgrass, there is J'accuse, with a suggestive lead photo:

https://static.wixstatic.com/media/85ddae_16b83b620e584300bf62be5f147f157d~mv2.jpeg
Link. No quote. It is there to read. And to ponder.

While that linked op-ed speculates a bit, it does post a link to a letter, this one, three pages long, by image, note the date, before the fan loaded up:



click each image to enlarge and read

LEAD LETTER AUTHOR: My rep, MN CD6, Tom Emmer, preceeded in office by Michele Bachmann, (but don't blame me), I've voted Dem. all along, but majority rules, however enlightened or ignorant.

That letter indicated Lizzy Fallon as contact person for the esteemed authors. 

Lizzy Fallon serves as a Financial Services Policy Advisor in the United States House of Representatives, leading the Representative’s Financial Services Committee portfolio, and specializing in policy related to fintech and blockchain/crypto. Additionally, Lizzy manages the Member’s co-chair responsibilities on the Blockchain Caucus.

Not an academic finance heavyweight, Fallon holds only a baccalaureate degree attained 2017, and prior to landing on FinServices staff was - 

        Research Associate - Parkhurst Energy
        May 2020 - Oct 2020 6 months
        Houston, Texas, United State
        
        GraphicSpecial Projects Intern  -
        The [Trump] White House
        May 2019 - Aug 2019 4 months

It is unclear who, if anyone, had any crypto/financial market expertise on the FinServices Committee staff (something that did not stop reps from favoring donor folks in the trade). 

..................................................

The post with the above crypto image of Rep. Emmer and an industry insider has very useful and informative recent links. Check them out. 

However, to even better understand today, look to a recent yesterday apart from that DWT item, from before crypto tanked, from the spring of this year, where it had cheerleaders, enablers, advocates, congress critters:

 The Skadden Arps lawfirm, possibly having skin in the game, on March 25, 2022, published: 

Congressional Blockchain Caucus Challenges SEC Chairman on Web3 Enforcement 

 The Web3 community has long expressed frustration at the lack of clarity emanating from the SEC regarding the treatment of cryptocurrencies and other digital assets under current securities laws, with many characterizing the agency’s activities as “regulation by enforcement.” The community now has an important ally in the so-called Congressional Blockchain Caucus, a bipartisan group of approximately 35 Congress members who describe themselves as those “who believe in the future of blockchain technology, and understand that Congress has a role to play in its development. As a Caucus, we have decided on a light touch regulatory approach.”

On March 16, 2022, Rep. Tom Emmer (R-MN) and seven other Congressional Blockchain Caucus members sent a letter to SEC Chairman Gary Gensler questioning the commission’s use of the Division of Enforcement and Division of Examination to obtain information related to “cryptocurrency and blockchain firms.” Specifically, the members assert that the SEC has been using the Enforcement Division’s investigative functions to gather information from cryptocurrency and blockchain companies in a manner inconsistent with the commission’s standards for initiating investigations and “at odds with” the Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA). The PRA, which was enacted in 1980, imposes certain approval requirements on government agencies seeking to obtain information from the public in order to minimize the burden on those from whom information is sought. In order to better understand the SEC’s authority to secure the information it seeks from blockchain firms — and to ensure these requests “are not over-burdensome, unnecessary, and do not stifle innovation” — the letter poses 13 questions to the SEC that center around the SEC’s activities in this space over the last five years.

Key Takeaway
Over the past year, certain Congress members have expressed
frustration with [SEC] Chairman Gensler’s approach to cryptocurrency,
voicing concerns that it may stifle innovation and prevent the U.S.
from being the global market leader in this area. While legislation
to address how cryptocurrencies and digital assets fit within the
federal securities laws’ framework is likely not on the short-term horizon, reliance on the PRA could provide an interesting angle by Congress to act as a check on the SEC’s efforts to collect information in this space.


[italics added] The gall of it. "As a Caucus, we have decided on a light touch regulatory approach.” Indeed. Not wanting to impede the new thing shaking things out expeditiously, free of red tape. It turned out to be unsolicited effort toward paying out rope for the perps to hang themselves. 

BUT - Donor perps, and that matters. 

NOTE - All the regularors were doing is keeping an eye on things, and that to Mr. Emmer and other Blockchain Caucus advocates was too much of a burden? Get real.

Fortune, March 18, 2022 - 

“Crypto startups must not be weighed down by extra-jurisdictional and burdensome reporting requirements,” Emmer wrote in a statement on his congressional website. “The SEC must ensure that its information-seeking requests to private crypto and blockchain firms are not overburdensome, unnecessary, and do not stifle innovation.”

The struggle between Emmer and his cosigners and the SEC boils down to how much control the agency has over private crypto companies. Emmer argues that although the SEC is able to request the voluntary interviews, testimonies, and the production of documents from entities it regulates, it is overreaching in its power. He also argues that the regulatory agency is applying this power to companies and entities not under its jurisdiction.

What is the Congressional Blockchain Caucus?

The Blockchain Caucus was founded during the 2015–16 session of Congress. It currently includes four chairs and 33 members from both parties, according to its website. 

The U.S. Congress has more than 400 caucuses, or groups of members of Congress with a common legislative objective. The Blockchain Caucus advocates for “a light touch” regulatory approach to blockchain technology like cryptocurrencies and NFTs.

Because of the Blockchain Caucus’s preference for light regulation, its members have sometimes clashed with the SEC, whose chair, Gensler, has characterized crypto markets as the “Wild West.”

In their most recent spat, several members of the caucus—though, not all—argued that two forms the SEC sends to crypto companies, Form 2866 and Form 1662, ask for much of the same information, which is burdensome to companies. Form 2866 asks crypto companies to send information like verification of their assets and an assessment of their company’s risks, and Form 1662 lays out the penalties for not disclosing these details.

Gee. Verification of assets. As in don't blow smoke. And risk assessment. Of all things. Selling investment opportunities, and being requested about such things, to Emmer it is unnecessary burden.

Can you imagine a greater burden? Apparently Emmer cannot. Nor, apparently can he see justification for such investor-friendly inquisition. Fraud prevention? Never enters his mind? More from Fortune -

Emmer wrote in the letter that under the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980, government agencies, when seeking information from the American public, “must be good stewards of the public’s time, and not overwhelm them with unnecessary or duplicative requests for information.”

[...] Under Gensler, the SEC has said little about blanket regulations for crypto and NFTs. Yet Gensler has made it clear that he has his eyes set on the industry. The SEC chair said earlier this year that he hopes the regulatory agency will start regulating cryptocurrency exchanges in 2022. Last week, President Biden’s executive order on crypto directed several federal agencies to study the drawbacks and benefits of crypto, possibly opening the door for new regulations.

Emmer said in a tweet that he has heard from many crypto and blockchain firms that

“SEC Chair @GaryGensler’s information reporting ‘requests’ to the crypto community are overburdensome, don’t feel particularly…voluntary…and are stifling innovation.”

Stifling innovative fraud might actually be sound government policy. And there is 20/20 hindsight.

Readers might learn more about the Blockchain Caucus, per this web search.

Noteworthy to be sure, via one of the hits from that search, we see congress critters can have some really bad ideas, authoritarian patriarchial anti-privacy ideas to undermine the very grounding of blockchain/crypto appeal and trust. Show sense. Being in Congress and showing sense are not wholly inimical, only too often alien to each other.

Back to the opening for a closing note. Somebody should try to untangle and publish about the follow the money thicket between the crypto promoters, their payments into politicians' campaigns, and the efforts of elected officials and paid political campaign folks to subsequently serve the desires of the donors, not biting the hand that feeds their lust for office and power. The DWT item linked to in opening this post alludes to Emmer as being too grateful for crypto campaign funds; but does not really document any such tie-in. We must be careful to not mischaracterise things.

So -

In effect, back to Emmer, and his hands on money as having been RNCC top dog this past election. What can crypto buy is a multifaceted question. It appears that donors pay real bucks to gain influence, not bit coin, but legal tender.

Yet without hard facts on dark money, we can only speculate; thanks to politics.

Thanks to Citizens United, decided as it was. Thanks to money and politics being of mixed concern to politicians. Regular Citizens are not conflicted that way.

 Now, wholly unrelated to Blockchain Caucus, crypto promoters, crypto enablers, political contributions, and claims of over-regulation bordering perhaps (implicitly but unstatedly so) as unmitigated pure harassment of exemplary people. Simply unrelated to any of the preceding. From the 40's, before crypto existed - a tune. 

Most likely a Quixotic tune. But catchy. In its own way easy to sing along.

_________UPDATE_________

Emmer on YouTube, about crypto, here, and interestingly here, the latter being interaction with a Financial Services Committee witness which is relevant today.

Both are about from a year ago, not today. The second video was embedded by Emmer into a tweet about "extensive guardrails" some crypto actors embrace. The tweet was noted by the Atlantic, in closing.

More Emmer, Breitbart and Minnesota Reformer.


OpenSecrets - see especially, items 6 and 15:

Contributors 2021 - 2022

$1,427,938

grand total of contributions Tom Emmer has reported in the current election cycle.
Number of Contributions from Individuals (of $200 or more): 1,322

Top 20 contributors to Campaign Committee

Top:
Rank Contributor Total Individuals PACs
1 Votesane PAC $106,000 $106,000 $0
2 Leamington Co $22,600 $22,600 $0
3 Hubbard Broadcasting $17,915 $17,915 $0
4 Timberland Transportation $17,400 $17,400 $0
5 Xcel Energy $16,250 $6,250 $10,000
6 Digital Currency Group $15,513 $15,513 $0
7 Starkey Hearing Technologies $14,000 $14,000 $0
8 National Assn of Broadcasters $12,650 $7,650 $5,000
9 Polaris Inc $12,000 $6,000 $6,000
10 King Capital Corp $11,600 $11,600 $0
11 Red Wing Publishing $11,600 $11,600 $0
12 Element Electronics $11,600 $11,600 $0
13 Dart Transit $11,600 $11,600 $0
14 Forward Financing $11,600 $11,600 $0
15 FTX.US $11,600 $11,600 $0
16 Anderson Trucking Service $11,600 $11,600 $0
17 Andreessen Horowitz $11,600 $11,600 $0
18 Arvig Enterprises $11,600 $11,600 $0
19 Affiliated Managers Group $11,600 $11,600 $0
20 UBS AG $11,000 $1,000 $10,000

*registrants, or active lobbying firm

These tables list the top donors to candidates in the 2021 - 2022 election cycle. The organizations themselves did not donate, rather the money came from the organizations' PACs, their individual members or employees or owners, and those individuals' immediate families. Organization totals include subsidiaries and affiliates.

 No proof of any quid-pro-quo has been found online. Emmer has larger donors than either of the crypto items. Circumstances can be viewed multiple ways, but Emmer is a big crypto booster, that is a fact, and one donor is now in hot water. How those two facts are read together should be leavened by an expectation of propriety.

Compare an earlier cycle's Emmer donors.

...............................................

The American Prospect IS a partisan site, not generally favorable to Republicans.

That said, this item dated Nov. 23, 2022, reports:

The Securities and Exchange Commission was seeking information from collapsed cryptocurrency exchange FTX earlier this year, the Prospect has confirmed, bringing a new perspective to an effort by a bipartisan group of congressmembers to slow down that investigation.

The March letter from eight House members—four Democrats and four Republicans—questioned the SEC’s authority to make informal inquiries to crypto and blockchain companies, and intimated that the requests violated federal law.

Rep. Tom Emmer (R-MN), whom the Republican caucus just elected as majority whip, the number three position in the House GOP leadership, led the letter. In a contemporaneous Twitter thread, Emmer wrote: “My office has received numerous tips from crypto and blockchain firms that SEC Chair @GaryGensler’s information reporting ‘requests’ to the crypto community are overburdensome, don’t feel particularly … voluntary … and are stifling innovation.”

We now know that FTX was one of those firms receiving information requests from the SEC, about the very activities that have brought down the firm. This raises the question of whether Emmer and the other congressmembers were acting on behalf of FTX (which has been credibly accused of snatching customer money to make risky bets) to try to chill an ongoing investigation from an independent regulatory and law enforcement agency.

[italics added] Note the posing of a question, and not an expression of probability. Same item, continuing -

More from David Dayen

Some of the “Blockchain Eight,” as the Prospect termed them in March, have benefited from crypto largesse. Five of the eight members received campaign donations from FTX employees, ranging from $2,900 to $11,600. Rep. Ted Budd (R-NC), one of the signatories, received half a million dollars in support from a Super PAC created by FTX co-CEO Ryan Salame.

More consequentially, Emmer was the head of the National Republican Congressional Committee, the campaign arm for House Republicans, this year. The NRCC’s associated super PAC, the Congressional Leadership Fund, received $2.75 million from FTX in the 2022 cycle; $2 million from Salame in late September, and $750,000 from the company’s political action committee.

That money helped House Republicans win the majority in 2022. Though FTX has been portrayed as a Democratic firm, thanks to the high profile of former co-CEO Sam Bankman-Fried, the company sprinkled around campaign donations fairly evenly, with a shade over 50 percent going directly to congressional Republicans and a shade under 50 percent to Democrats this cycle.

In an email, the SEC declined to comment. Six of the eight congressmembers have yet to respond to the Prospect’s inquiries.

[...] REUTERS REPORTED LAST FRIDAY on an internal FTX document, showing that the SEC had made informal inquiries earlier this year to FTX and other firms about how they handled customer deposits. As we now know, FTX was funneling customer funds to its associated trading firm Alameda Research. The newly installed CEO of FTX, John Ray, told a bankruptcy court last week about a “complete lack of corporate controls” at the company.

The SEC also asked FTX about a rewards program that gave depositors interest on their crypto assets, which could make them a security. SEC chair Gary Gensler has been adamant that crypto platforms are trading and minting securities, and that these securities needed to be registered with the agency. Crypto firms have generally failed to register anything.

In response to the inquiry, FTX asserted that the rewards program did not involve any lending and was aboveboard. The SEC then replied that it did not need further information “at this time.”

Timing of such FTX and SEC activity, re the timing of the Emmer - Blockchain Eight letter would be of interest, but timing of the SEC - FTX dealings could not be pinned down. More from the American Prospect item:

 Emmer made clear in his March Twitter thread that the letter was based on complaints from crypto firms, and that his intent was to stop the SEC from making these inquiries. “Crypto startups must not be weighed down by extra-jurisdictional and burdensome reporting requirements,” Emmer wrote. “We will ensure our regulators do not kill American innovation and opportunities.”

On the flip side, Emmer was quick to laud Bankman-Fried for his integrity and compliance with the law. In December 2021, Bankman-Fried testified before Congress, and Emmer told him, “Sounds like you’re doing a lot to make sure there is no fraud or other manipulation.”

Emmer and Gottheimer led the Blockchain Eight in donations from FTX with each receiving $11,600. FTX was in the top 15 of Emmer’s biggest donors in the 2022 cycle. Auchincloss received $6,800, and Budd and Torres received $2,900.

Coinbase has also contributed to members of the Blockchain Eight. Emmer received $2,900 from Coinbase’s PAC in 2022; Gottheimer got $2,900 from a Coinbase employee, and Auchincloss got $2,000.

Budd was the beneficiary of roughly $517,000 in spending from co-CEO Salame’s Super PAC, American Dream Federal Action.

But the millions in funds from FTX’s PAC and Salame to the House Republicans’ Congressional Leadership Fund dwarf the spending to individual candidates. As the lead signatory of the letter and the member who said he’d received “tips” from crypto firms that informed that letter, and as the head of House Republicans’ campaign arm, Emmer had the most to gain from a large donation to help the GOP win the majority. “We delivered,” Emmer said after the majority was secured.

Salame gave $23.6 million to exclusively Republican candidates and causes in the 2022 cycle, in contrast to Bankman-Fried, whose $40 million went to Democrats. A handful of members, including Reps. Chuy GarcĂ­a (D-IL) and Kevin Hern (R-OK), have returned FTX donations, and Sens. Dick Durbin (D-IL) and Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) have donated the contributions to charity. None of the Blockchain Eight have yet said what they would do with their own FTX donations.

The catastrophe at FTX hasn’t stopped Emmer from continuing to boost crypto.

THE UNORTHODOX LETTER IS ANALOGOUS to the 1987 “Keating Five” scandal. Then, five senators (including a young Arizona Republican named John McCain) pressured the Federal Home Loan Bank Board (FHLBB) into shutting down an investigation into Lincoln Savings and Loan and its chair Charles Keating Jr. Keating was a donor to all five senators, giving $1.3 million over the years.

There is a bit more, but comparing the Emmer situation to the Keating Six and the S&L failure is speculative, and suggestive. At present it is premature conjecture.

__________FURTHER UPDATE__________

Emmer campaign page,

https://emmerforcongress.com/donate-with-crypto/

indicates donor intent to contribute in cryptocurrency would be accepted.

Another campaign page, 

https://emmerforcongress.com/2020/08/20/emmer-leads-first-cryptocurrency-town-hall-accepts-crypto-contributions/

states:

Emmer Leads First Cryptocurrency Town Hall, Accepts Crypto Contributions

For Immediate Release
August 20, 2020
Contact: Zach Freimark (612) 804-1771
press@emmerforcongress.com

[...]

Congressman Emmer partnered with the Chamber of Digital Commerce PAC to facilitate the town hall and featured leaders from the blockchain & crypto industry, including Jeremy Allaire, CEO of Circle, Brad Garlinghouse, CEO of Ripple, Guy Hirsch, USA Managing Director at eToro, Stephen Pair, CEO of BitPay, Matthew Roszak, Chairman and Co-Founder of Bloq, and Chad Cascarilla, CEO and Co-founder of Paxos.

https://www.linkedin.com/in/zachary-freimark-60640111 - identifies Freimark as

 Experience

  • NRCC Graphic

    Regional Political Director

    NRCC

    - Present3 years 10 months

  • Senior Advisor

    Emmer for Congress

    - Present4 years

    United States

  • District Representative

    Congressman Tom Emmer

    - 4 years 3 months

  • Political Director

    Mike McFadden for Senate

    - 5 months

  • Consultant

    Scott Honour for Governor

    - 7 months

  • Consultant

    Emmer for Congress

    - 7 months

  • Senior Account Manager

    Civis Communications

    - 4 months

    Plymouth, MN

  • Republican Party of Minnesota Graphic

    Political Director

    Republican Party of Minnesota

    - 3 years 9 months

  • Political Director

    Roy Brown for Governor

    - 6 months

  • Deputy Campaign Manager/Director of Field Operations

    Brian Davis for Congress

    - 6 months

  • Volunteer Coordinator

    Jim Ramstad Volunteer Committee

    - 1 year

Education

This suggests a political operative, not an economics heavyweight, where the expectation is that Freimark is not the driving force behind Emmer's understandings of cryptocurrency value, trading, market, and credability.

That in turn suggests Emmer's reliance in and promotion of crypto has another base than Freimark, presumably the host of  Townhall participants above named, and the Chamber of Digital Commerce PAC, above named.

Reliance upon market participants carries a bias, if that is how Emmer relied.

It seems incumbent upon Emmer, now in today's realities, to explain what he and the witness are saying in the video (posted first online by Emmer) now placed onto the sidebar. As best as Crabgrass understands it, Emmer is complaining that crypto exchanges are under SEC scrutiny, denial, or discrediting while derivatives on crypto are SEC-allowed to be traded, presumably by conventional derivative trading houses. 

If that is incorrect, we hope Emmer will be enlarging and revising his video remarks in the near future for clarity, i.e., to make clear to regular people why he is so avid a crypto promoter. And not in easy generalities, touting the next big thing, but how in detail he sees investor reliance in crypto a sound thing. He should identify his advisors on the technicalities of what he is promoting. Else, conclusions can range into areas Emmer might want to disarm.

Of those Townhall participants, readers, have you ever heard of any or have any idea of professional credibility any one of them holds among economists and bankers? Yes, crypto is a challenge to central banking and central bankers, and to banks happily under the Fed's umbrella while they run the Fed, but that does not gut nor bolster crypto credibility.

In effect: What's the story, Tom? Spell out a host of detail, please? Make it hang together and make sense to ordinary minds, and to lawyers who might wonder.

Something beyond a puff-piece in Breitbart, please.


click image to enlarge and read

That Breitbart item continues beyond the screen capture:

As the Fed failed to curb inflation, it has moved to hike interest rates to fight back against decades-high inflation.

To aid cryptocurrencies’ mission to serve as a counterbalance to mismanaged monetary policy, Emmer said the federal government could provide a more clear regulatory environment and ensure that Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) chairman Gary Gensler does not have “rogue authority” to regulate the burgeoning crypto industry.

Emmer said, “In order for us to start to move forward on this you have to at least start to define what is cash? What is a commodity, what is a security? It makes, frankly, securities lawyers rich. They like to go when we got the Howey Test. The Howey Test was created during a time when digital currencies weren’t even a thing. I think it’s time to define those terms.”

The Howey Test refers to the U.S. Supreme Court case for determining whether a transaction amounts to an “investment contract” and would be a security and thus subject to disclosure and registration requirements under the SEC.

The Howey Test is an important issue in the digital currency community, as many digital currencies and blockchain technologies such as Ethereum may qualify as a security, and thus fall under Gensler’s regulatory purview.

The Minnesota Republican sponsored the Securities Clarity Act to help innovation flourish by clarifying that a digital currency token is separate and distinct from a traditional security.

Emmer continued, “I don’t believe in creating another regulatory or regulator and other regulatory agency. I think we can do it within the ones we already have. But we have to start defining them so we know that Gary Gensler does not have rogue authority over every aspect of the crypto community. I think that would be first and foremost from a general statement, what we’d need to do.”

Emmer, a member of the Congressional Blockchain Caucus, sponsored many bills to provide a more clear regulatory approach and to prevent stifling innovation in the financial technology sphere. This includes:

  • H.R. 6415, which would prohibit Federal Reserve banks from offering central bank digital currencies (CBDCs), which many argue would grant nearly totalitarian levels of control over Americans’ money
  • The Blockchain Regulatory Certainty Act, which would provide regulatory clarity to blockchain innovators.

Emmer also said that Republicans, if they take the House majority during the congressional midterms, would hold members of the Biden administration accountable, such as Gensler, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) Director Rohit Chopra, and Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen.

“These people think they’re above the law, above Congress’s supervision, and they’re not,” Emmer said. He said the Biden administration remains hostile to crypto despite the potential it has for the country and the world.

Emmer said, “This administration is not just the guy at the top, but the administration is littered with people who I would argue are not favorable towards the crypto space in frankly, the promise that it holds in terms of opportunity for all Americans and people around the world.”

 Does this "exposition" pass your credibility litmus test, where admittedly the Fed and monetary policy can be criticized? How does crypto make things more stable and less cyclical, when co-existing with the Fed, and beyond current players not wanting competition, why would the Fed issuing its own crypto be a bad (or good) thing? Right now we have crypto, decentralized - spun off in different "token" batches by private sector promoters, as "money" but does it carry the trust that a fiat currency must have, such as the dollar or treasuary bonds? 

I don't know. Do your know? Does Tom Emmer know? Does Tom Emmer really care beyond crypto folks funding campaigns? Only Tom Emmer knows the answer to that last one.

Emmer appears to have made statements - bald assertions - without any bases in truth or logic offered to justify or underpin what he says.

Do you understand why any prudent person should invest in and rely on crypto?

Why crypto trading is anything beyond a casino with insiders who Townhall us along  with Emmer, while you have never heard of them and have no real cause offered to trust their product?

___________FURTHER UPDATE___________

To the extent context might help readers focus upon the Emmer questioning aimed specifically at FTX, the hearing from which that segment was excerpted and posted by Rep. Emmer is online here, two and a quarter hours, and the Emmer interchange is at roughly the 54 and a half minute mark. The item seems to start without an identification of witnesses, etc., but mid hearing. 

From following the entire process it is easier to understand the committee members each had particular focused attention toward one or another specific aspect of crypto/blockchain and the distributed vs. centralized nature of the process, as well as other dimensions. With five minutes per member, nobody could range too widely in attention and inquiry. Emmer seemed focused upon price discovery, in derivative trading. The reliability of it. Other Reps. during their time looked at Blockchain apart from crypto usage, and the caucus is "The Blockchain Caucus," not specifically focused upon crypto, which is the major Blockchain application domain at present. 

A much wider range of utilization of Blockchain has been noted as feasible, and arguably desirable, with its uniqueness. Crabgrass is not yet versed in the nuances and potential, not owning or following crypto until reading the DWT item critical of Rep. Emmer. Keeping an open mind because of such ignorance of the topic is necessary, and an effort is being made to "study up" to gain a better understanding. E.g., online hearings touch policy and regulatory possibilities or needs, while this link might start a reader on technical discovery.

 [UPDATE - As one example, one Rep. noted how crypto might allow prompt low cost sending of money by a worker stateside to family in another nation without the cost, delay, and impediments of using banking intermediation to handle such transfers. Clearly a different focus than Emmer's in that questioning segment. Emmer however has otherwise touted crypto as an empowering thing for low end folks in the economy, and such sending aid back home fits Emmer's general remarks in that direction.]

FURTHER: Ars Tech. indicates Bankman-Fried may likely be testifying before a House Committee, with possibly a Senate hearing too, both later this month. Rep. Emmer would likely be questioning him again, if the anticipated House hearing actually comes to pass. Moreover -

Websearch = Bankman-Fried testifying this month congress

The likelihood of such upcoming testimony is widely reported.

.....................................

Those interested in blockchain, an easy non-tech online item, here. Enthusiastic. Dated.

More recent, last month, here, make of it what you will.



Monday, December 05, 2022

General background on abortion as a political issue, via an image selection from a Ballotpedia webpage, showing some state-by-state information.

image source

click the image to enlarge and read

Ramsey City Council fiscal action is reported by ABC Newspapers.

 Ramsey approves 10-year capital improvement plan

NOW is time to properly enshrine privacy and the subsumed right to reproductive freedom / body autonomy into Minnesota's Constitution. Such a step should definitively forestall a rogue judge from holding abortion unconstitutional in Minnesota. Delay is both counterproductive and unjustified. The only issue should be the question of wording. Getting it done as State policy is not a question. It has to be done, given the will shown by the electorate this past November.

 Ballotpedia has a generic online page related to 2022 election abortion ballot issues. (Including info re potential upcoming issues in other states.)

In the recent election anti-abortion proposals failed in Kentucky and Montana. 

In Montana -

The measure failed by around 20,000 votes, with 52.6% voting against it and 47.4% in favor of its passage at the time The Associated Press called the race.

"A health care provider performing an abortion shall take all medically appropriate and reasonable steps to preserve the life and health of a born-alive infant who is viable. If an abortion performed in a hospital results in a live birth of a viable infant, the health care provider shall provide immediate medical care to the infant," the ballot measure stated.

In Kentucky - 

Over half, or 51.90% of voters, said “No” to the legislation, which would have undermined abortion rights advocates’ fight against Kentucky’s six-week and near-total abortion bans in court.

Now that it has failed, though, the League of Women Voters said the Kentucky Supreme Court can now choose to strike down the state’s current ban on abortion at conception.

 [...] The ACLU of Kentucky filed a lawsuit challenging Kentucky’s abortion bans on behalf of EMW Women’s Surgical Center and Planned Parenthood, saying it caused individuals to “remain pregnant against their will.”

Kentucky wording -

The measure would have added section 26A to the state constitution's bill of rights. The following underlined text would be added: Section 26A. To protect human life, nothing in this Constitution shall be construed to secure or protect a right to abortion or require the funding of abortion.

...................................................

Constitutional amendments enshrining abortion as a right passed in California, Vermont, and Michigan.

 

......................CALIFORNIA......................

After passage, a Section 1.1. was added to the California Constitution, which now reads -

 Section 1

All people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy.

Section 1.1

The state shall not deny or interfere with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions, which includes their fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and their fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives. This section is intended to further the constitutional right to privacy guaranteed by Section 1, and the constitutional right to not be denied equal protection guaranteed by Section 7. Nothing herein narrows or limits the right to privacy or equal protection.

Amendments Section 1.1 was added with the approval of Proposition 1 on November 8, 2022.

 

................................MICHIGAN...........................

Passage of the amendment ballot measure in November added Section 28 to Article I, Michigan Constitution of the Michigan Constitution via the following text being added:

 Article 1, Section 28 Right to Reproductive Freedom

(1) Every individual has a fundamental right to reproductive freedom, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy, including but not limited to prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, sterilization, abortion care, miscarriage management, and infertility care.

An individual's right to reproductive freedom shall not be denied, burdened, nor infringed upon unless justified by a compelling state interest achieved by the least restrictive means.

Notwithstanding the above, the state may regulate the provision of abortion care after fetal viability, provided that in no circumstance shall the state prohibit an abortion that, in the professional judgment of an attending health care professional, is medically indicated to protect the life or physical or mental health of the pregnant individual.

(2) The state shall not discriminate in the protection or enforcement of this fundamental right.

(3) The state shall not penalize, prosecute, or otherwise take adverse action against an individual based on their actual, potential, perceived, or alleged pregnancy outcomes, including but not limited to miscarriage, stillbirth, or abortion. Nor shall the state penalize, prosecute, or otherwise take adverse action against someone for aiding or assisting a pregnant individual in exercising their right to reproductive freedom with their voluntary consent.

(4) For the purposes of this section:

A state interest is "compelling" only if it is for the limited purpose of protecting the health of an individual seeking care, consistent with accepted clinical standards of practice and evidence-based medicine, and does not infringe on that individual's autonomous decision-making. "Fetal viability" means: the point in pregnancy when, in the professional judgment of an attending health care professional and based on the particular facts of the case, there is a significant likelihood of the fetus's sustained survival outside the uterus without the application of extraordinary medical measures.
(5) This section shall be self-executing. Any provision of this section held invalid shall be severable from the remaining portions of this section.

 

.............................VERMONT............................

After passage in the November election, Vermont Proposal 5, Right to Personal Reproductive Autonomy Amendment (2022) amended the State's Constitution via text as follows -

The ballot measure added an Article 22 to Chapter I of the Vermont Constitution. The following text states the new provision:

Article 22. Personal reproductive liberty.

That an individual’s right to personal reproductive autonomy is central to the liberty and dignity to determine one’s own life course and shall not be denied or infringed unless justified by a compelling State interest achieved by the least restrictive means.

......................................................................

Michigan's provision is quite detailed for a Constitutional provision. Severability provided for in a Constitutional Section is a unique idea, but preemptive federal legislation might be later passed, with SCOTUS, the federal Supreme Court, having to rule on Michigan's provision and extent of preemption might be aided by the "severable" language. Neither of the three provisions gets into regulation of provision/providers, licensing, barring onerous red tape harassment of providers, or penalty for back-alley operations but without onerous impediment against legitimate professional providers.

Michigan's language expressly decriminalizes assisting exercise of the right:

Nor shall the state penalize, prosecute, or otherwise take adverse action against someone for aiding or assisting a pregnant individual in exercising their right to reproductive freedom with their voluntary consent.

 

____________UPDATE____________

With the DFL having legislative and executive control in Minnesota through 2024, the expectation would be that legislative options will be explored and passed. If a Constitutional Amendment is proposed and promulgated, expect it to be a timed to be part of the November 2024 election, and not via a special election. Special election turnout can be sparse and tricky, and expect the DFL if proposing an amendment at all to want it to have maximal GOTV dimensions for it and in other contests.

The DFL might collectively feel more confident in legislating only, leaving Constitutional amendment out of reforms, because legislation can be rewritten, making a stronger case for keeping the DFL trifecta intact into the future to quell rescinding of legislation; whereas Constututional revisionism requires a plebiscite as well as legislative majority. Keeping the issue front burner might be thought politically advantageous over nailing things down tighter via Constitutional proposals, which might always fail in popular voting.

We wait. We see.


What text might serve a Minnesota Constitutional Amendment adding reproductive freedom as an express Constitutional right?

 Possible Minnesota Constitutional language - Article 1, new Section 18:

 

Section 18. Right to private personal body autonomy.

In support of the free and independent and inalienable rights of all people in Minnesota such as enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy, the state shall not deny or interfere with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions, which includes their fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and their fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives; this prohibition being intended to further the constitutional right to privacy and the constitutional right to not be denied equal protection. Nothing herein narrows or limits the right to privacy or equal protection. Contraception shall be available in every licensed pharmacy, over the counter and not requiring a physician's presciption, and no pharmacy employee may deny or curtail access, especially for medications where timely use is of the essence. Assertion of unborn being "human persons" whose lives may not be terminated fails as a matter of law to raise a valid claim of a compelling state interest against unimpeded widespread safe medical abortion availability. The State may have an interest in reasonable non-burdensome collection of anonymized statistical data so long as specific detailed patient privacy of medical-professional and pharmacy consultation and services remains recognized as essential. No civil or criminal penalty may attach to error or claimed inadequacy of any such mandated reporting. All parts of this section shall be self-executing and any subsequent federal preemption of any part shall be of minimal intrusion upon the range of freedoms recognized; such range including the absence of civil or criminal penalty for one assisting another in exercising reproductive freedom. Severability exists, with the entire provision not intended to be voided as a whole if any part is voided.

Opening language would preamble that reproductive freedom is equivalent to other of our most fundamental rights; and privacy is expressly written as a right underpinning reproductive freedom rights. 

Questions of "marriage" are expressly not intermixed, Occam's Razor applying. 

California's wording is the main template for the suggested wording. Putting it all in a single paragraph is intentional. Some provisions intentionally go beyond any of the three other state amendments, especially re pharmaceuticals and pharmacies. The intent is to foreclose ways already proposed elsewhere at tearing away the freedom a bit at a time. Making reproductive freedom a fundamental right akin to those mentioned early in the text indirectly requires a compelling state interest to narrow the reach, with "unborn rights" expressly voided as a compelling state interest. 

Specific language, ". . . unimpeded widespread safe medical abortion availability" is specific enough to suggest minimal to no tampering with the freedom can be justified, with specific "unborn" objections expressly foreclosed, Constitutionally.

Medical professional is used and not physician, deliberately; while that term recognizes back alley unprofessional procedures might happen, distinguished from legit practice. Clearly truly unsafe practice can be criminalized or otherwise constrained. That is an inherent police power of the State.

Things such as parental notice, cooling off periods, forced consultations about "options," and requiring abortion providers to have hospital rights in case of emergency, those are proposals that have been trotted out to impede reproductive freedom; however, with a constitutional right recognized in "unimpeded widespread safe medical abortion availability" such questionable impediments will have a harder time being defended.

Detail recognized in the Michigan amendment is included at the end, where precise wording need not exactly parallel the way Michigan said things.

Language cannot help being elastic, and having express Constitutional provision of reproductive freedom resting in part upon an acknowledged right to privacy will not quell litigation or legislative encroachment opportunists. Filing a complaint requires having the filing fee, which is not an onerous thing. Passing an onerous bill requires a majority of both legislative houses and executive approval or a veto override, so the system has its checks and balances where the weight of Constitutional guidance should be accorded respect in the event an amendment resolution is passed.

Saturday, December 03, 2022

Pioneer Press reports Dems new early primary decisions.

Link, in part-

National Democratic Party leadership passed on Minnesota as an early presidential primary state for 2024, despite appeals from top state party officials.

Early presidential primaries can end up shaping the major party nominees for the nation’s highest office.

Under a plan approved by a key panel of the Democratic National Committee on Friday, South Carolina will hold the first 2024 presidential primary Feb. 3, followed by New Hampshire and Nevada on Feb. 6. Georgia would hold its primary Feb. 20, and Michigan’s primary would be Feb. 27.

South Carolina? Front running for Clyburn? The Black vote?

South Carolina, Michigan, first and same day would make more sense.  And then, ten to twenty days later, same day, Georgia, Pennsylvania and California. 

Populous states, different regions. And really, how many electoral votes does South Carolina represent? Ditto, Nevada? Ditto New Hampshire?

Kick the tires where the electoral votes are plentiful, instead of otherwise.

Winnow early. Fairly.

More from the PiPress item-

President Joe Biden sent a letter to the panel Thursday asking party leadership to ensure voters of color have a voice much earlier in the nomination process. South Carolina’s Democratic primary would give Black voters more of a voice in the process, backers of giving the state the first primary argued. The new schedule approved Friday afternoon reflects the president’s requests to the DNC.

“For decades, Black voters in particular have been the backbone of the Democratic Party but have been pushed to the back of the early primary process,” the president wrote to party leadership. “It is time to stop taking these voters for granted, and time to give them a louder and earlier voice in the process.”

Iowa lost its spot as the opening contest in the race for the White House, a position it has held since 1972. Critics say Iowa is too homogeneous to continue serving as a presidential launching pad in a country that’s growing more diverse.

Biden in his letter also urged the Democratic Party to no longer allow states to hold caucuses in the nominating process, calling the process too time-consuming and unfair to anyone who does not have the flexibility to participate due to a job or other obligations. Iowa still holds caucuses, while Minnesota held its last presidential caucuses in 2016 before switching to a primary in 2020.

In their pitch to the national party for an early primary, the DFL presented Minnesota as “Democracy’s North Star,” highlighting the state’s high voter participation, civic engagement, a concentration of rural Democratic voters, growing ethnic diversity and strong LGBTQ community.

“To be successful in Minnesota, candidates need to win over voters in urban, suburban and rural communities, and they will need to appeal to an electorate that is rapidly diversifying,” Martin said.

Gov. Tim Walz, House Speaker Melissa Hortman and incoming Senate Majority Leader Kari Dziedzic sent a letter to the DNC pledging to pass legislation to move Minnesota’s primary to an earlier date if national leadership picked the state.

How it could be better vs. how it is. Biden last time surely owes South Carolina, and Clyburn in particular; but the rest of the party and nation matter more than owed favors between octogenarians. 

UPDATE: Gretchen Whitmer, hat in the ring and all, must like Michigan early. Yet if she does not substantially move the needle early there, hang the hat and watch the rest of the show?

FURTHER: If Biden does run again, expect South Carolina as it was last cycle, with perhaps Black voting in Georgia and Detroit following, possibly in lockstep with Clyburn, party over? 

It is early, just under two years to the 2024 general election, with Biden the incumbent; so what matters? Other hopefuls will have to define themselves in 2023 in order to ring any bells in Feb. 2024. Harris? There's better.

FURTHER: At least Elon cannot run, either party, being born in South Africa. Bezos could run, born in New Mexico.

Expect more grandstanding from DeSantis early and often in 2023. Name recognition uber alles? Trump as insufferable as ever.



Minnesota's DFL suffers from one less thorn in its side than Minnesota's GOP. The DFL is not currently being sued by a former insider with an asserted claim other insiders wrongly "disparaged" the suing one - who wants money. Jennifer Carnahan sues, claiming nondispargement contract rights; the MN GOP says, not so, and counterclaims. So far, the DFL has less contentious interrelationships, or at least does not air them out in public seeking damages.

 Ms. Carnahan has an online tout page via the mbda.gov, a federal body, the Minority Business and Development Agency. Among other things we learn there, "While at General Mills, Jennifer managed promotions for several brands within the Pillsbury Division, including: Totino's Pizza Rolls and Toaster Strudel."

While the remainder of this post could justifiably refer to Ms. Carnahan as "the Pillsbury Totino's Pizza Rolls and Toaster Strudel whiz-bang promotional strategist," restraint suggests "Ms. Carnahan" or simply "Carnahan" shall be used in all further references.

The mbda page is referenced primarily to show a promotional background, including self-promotion, which her having that page evidences. Also online, 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jennifer_Carnahan

................................................................

Enough background, Brian Bakst authored a Dec. 2 MPR post, "Fierce legal fight opens between ex-GOP chair Carnahan, party," explaining in part -

Former Minnesota Republican Party Chair Jennifer Carnahan sued the state party in relation to her ouster, claiming that her ability to gain new jobs in politics was damaged by remarks made by past colleagues.

Carnahan’s lawsuit filed Thursday in Hennepin County District Court alleges she was improperly disparaged in violation of a separation agreement she signed in August 2021. Carnahan resigned amid allegations of a hostile work environment and other internal troubles. She was paid about $38,000 when she stepped down.

The party immediately fired back with a countersuit that said Carnahan’s actions damaged the party’s reputation. The counteraction also criticized Carnahan’s association with a major operative and donor who is facing a raft of federal charges.

Carnahan declined comment when reached by phone. But her attorney, Matthew Schaap, said the exit contract was breached.

“A number of people who were involved with the party and bound by the agreement were on social media and in the public essentially saying negative things and disparaging Ms. Carnahan publicly, acting almost as though the contract didn't exist,” Schaap said.

[...] Carnahan is seeking monetary damages in excess of $50,000, which is a standard amount listed in civil actions in Minnesota. She has kept a low profile since running unsuccessfully this spring for her late husband Jim Hagedorn’s congressional seat in southern Minnesota.

Schaap said Carnahan has faced several repercussions.

“When things are are [sic] said in the press, particularly negative things about Ms. Carnahan, they have an impact on her reputation, they have an impact on her ability to find work, to participate in politics,” he said in a phone interview Friday. “And so it's had a significant impact on her reputation in the community.”

The legal action commenced in September but remained behind the scenes. There was back-and-forth between Carnahan’s side and people within the party, who last month lodged counterclaims. 

The case became public when it was formally filed.

It sprang into the open just before a weekend gathering of Republicans in St. Cloud to pick leaders and dissect the election.

Give the conveners something extra to discuss? What?

....................................................................

Worth noting, the report links to key pleadings, the complaint and the answer-counterclaim, as posted on DocumentCloud online, by Bakst.

A couple of things appear unclear to Crabgrass. Substantively, a defamation claim allows truth as an absolute defense. If true negative things are published, harm to reputation arising from that does not merit defamation damages.

Would Minnesota courts apply the same standard "truth defense" as applicable to "breach of a written nondispargement contract?" Or will a court look to the promise in the "contract" to see if, in effect, it has gag order dimensions, true or false? 

Or is the more standard practice to contest existence of a valid contract; i.e., to put meeting of the minds at issue, despite a signed document, under a fraud or breach of fiduciary duty counterclaim?

Procedurally, it appears a complaint and answer-counterclaim were served and not initially filed. On Dec. 1, Ms. Carnahan's lawyer filed - same day - the complaint and an answer to the counterclaim, with no counterclaim filed. Reporting posts an amended answer and counterclaim. Is there need to move to amend, given that strange filing history? Likely so, to be fully clear. The filed Carnahan response to the "counterclaim" does not say, "amended counterclaim," so what's up?

THE FOLLOWING COMMENTARY IS BASED ON THE TWO LINKED AND POSTED DOCUMENTS, AS ABOVE REFERENCED, IN QUOTING THE MPR REPORT: 

Carnahan's basic claim for breach of contract is that there was mutual consideration backing a valid contract provision, drafted by the party's counsel, signed by a party official, with key Complaint paragraphs:

 26. Based on the onslaught of false claims against her, Ms. Carnahan decided to step down from her role as Chairwoman, entering into a Separation Agreement, Waiver and Release (“Agreement”) with MN GOP, effective August 19, 2021.

27. The Agreement required MN GOP, its management employees, Officers, and Executive Board Members to refrain from disparaging Ms. Carnahan “in any respect.” 

28. The non-disparagement provision of the Agreement was important to Ms. Carnahan given prior efforts by some MN GOP party leaders to disparage her by spreading negative stories about her in the community.

The thrust of the amended counterclaim is that the non-disparagement writing was procured by Carnahan via breach of fiduciary duty, lack of notice to key party persons, and is not a valid contract. That, in effect, there never was a meeting of the minds between Carnahan and necessary party officials, despite there being a signed document:

1. As Chair of the Republican Party of Minnesota (“RPM”), Jennifer Carnahan was entrusted to steward one of Minnesota’s two major political parties. Rather than seeking to carefully advance the interest of this vital institution, Carnahan recklessly pursued her own interests. Throughout her tenure as RPM Chair, Carnahan mismanaged the party to advance her own personal, political, and financial interests, as well as the interests of her friends. When her close personal relationship with Tony Lazzaro brought disrepute to the RPM following his arrest on federal charges relating to sex trafficking of minors, numerous other concerns with her mismanagement of the party came to light, including her penchant for using party resources to purchase the silence of former party staffers through non-disclosure agreements. 

2. Even after it was clear she would be removed as RPM’s Chair, Carnahan continued to abuse her position of trust and responsibility for her own personal benefit. As her final act as RPM Chair, Carnahan voted to directly advance her own personal interests, casting the deciding vote as a member of the Executive Committee to award herself a severance payment of $38,500. Carnahan then resigned her position as Chair. 

3. Carnahan knew that the Executive Committee had not discussed, let alone voted to authorize any non-disparagement agreement with Carnahan. Yet, Carnahan orchestrated the drafting of such an agreement, which was purportedly signed on behalf of RPM by the Interim Chair. Carnahan was aware that the Interim Chair had no authority to execute a nondisparagement agreement. Despite her knowledge that no agreement was validly authorized, Carnahan threatened to sue, and ultimately brought suit, based on RPM’s alleged violations of this purported agreement. 

4. At every step of the process, Carnahan has violated her legal duties to RPM, culminating in this frivolous lawsuit. RPM is now forced to assert its legal rights, and is entitled to monetary damages as well as declaratory and other relief, as set forth herein.

The Crabgrass view is that it is a common situation when a signed writing exists to have evidence presented to the trial's finder of fact (Carnahan requests a jury trial) as to whether facts outside of the "four corners" of the writing demonstrate there never was a true meeting of minds, and/or that the writing was wrongfully procured or otherwise is not enforceable. 

Also, whether "truth is a total defense" as with defamation actions is the law of non-dispargement writings would be a question of law for the trial judge.

Minnesota House Rep. Elect, Harry Niska is of counsel representing the party, but not lead counsel (Samuel W. Diehl signed the pleading). This is not the first time Niska has represented the Minnesota Republican Party in litigation. (UPDATE: see online, here and here, re the interests of his party)

..............................................................

Coincidentally, Sorensen has posted news related to Carnahan recently, at her Bluestem Prairie website:

https://www.bluestemprairie.com/

............................................................

_________UPDATE_________

RIGHT TO RELY? Upon reflection, it seems the RPM (Republican Party of Minnesota) in reserving its right to add affirmative defenses, should quickly add the defense that Carnahan had no rational or reasonable right to rely upon a belief she had attained a blanket gag order against individuals, particularly individuals in politics where speaking on their own behalf is a critical power and right.

At best for Carnahan, aside from any other infirmity in the document that might prevail against her, she can only interpret the document in a reasonable fashion, i.e., that the RPM would not have any individual of the type mentioned speak against her in a capacity of agent or representative of the RPM.

From the complaint it is unclear that Carnahan even alleges that any asserted commentary unfavorable to her was done in behalf of and/or as agent for the RPM.

Social media posts, for example, on personal websites or on say Twitter under a personal and not representative hashtag, cannot reasonably be thought of as an RPM action. 

Persons have the right to express opinions or make representations of fact, and if false representations of fact are made, they are actionable under defamation law, against the speaker/publisher.

 Opinion expressions are not actionable as defamatory. To be a republican and to also personally express an opinion that Carnahan should never have been given separation money - how can the party stop any person from stating that opinion as a personal belief; and if the party obviously cannot, than how can Carnahan, herself an experienced politician, realistically and reasonably believe the RPM is in breach of any duty?

It has been asserted she, in the past, used party money to purchase nondisclosure agreements of departing officials. That shows she knew that binding a person meant getting that person into a contract.

Multiple people are alleged to have stated things. Back to the question then, did Carnahan have any reasonable cause ever to harbor a true belief or expectation that the RPM could prevent them, as individual citizens with rights, from speaking/publishing true things?

Isn't that the the most fundamental dimension of the entire litigation posture?

Based on her own prior conduct and achievement of a party leadership position, with the understanding and sophistication that goes with that; how in all creation can she now claim a wholly fanciful expectation, regardless of any other aspect of things, that the RPM could bargain away civil rights of Republican persons? 

BOTTOM LINE; It beggars the imagination, to see she is suing RPM for what apparently amounts to other individuals - in their individual capacity - exercising their civil rights.

Furthermore, as to defamation New York Times v. Sullivan requires a showing of actual malice, since Carnahan clearly is a public figure.

This is all my opinion, which I have the right to hold and express. It is NOT giving advice to anyone. It is saying how I view things.

___________FURTHER UPDATE___________

In stating her breach of contract cause of action at the end of her complaint, Carnahan asserts-

44. As a result of the disparaging statements made by agents of MN GOP, Ms. Carnahan has lost new work opportunities, and she has suffered emotional distress, and other general and special damages, in an amount to be proven at trial, but reasonably believed to exceed $50,000.00.

[italics added] It seems Carnahan's burden of proof would be "made as agents of Mn GOP" and not merely "while agents."  I.e., can she prove the people whose commentary she dislikes were speaking as agents of the party, and not simply exercising their personal civil rights? And if the latter is the story, she does not sue them for defamation, individually, with the defenses that exist against a  public person asserting defamation, under an actual malice proof standard; true statements and opinion being at issue also as defenses. There is a concept of "defamation per se" but this is not a defamation suit, it is a contract claim.

DAMAGES? Prior to that ending cause of action pleading she has not pleaded as fact any specific lost work opportunity, nor any treatment regimen for emotional distress. Is anger a form of emotional distress, and would a jury be sympathetic to sitting through a lawsuit over anger alone? 

She does have to prove damages at trial. Discovery should be expected to be aimed in part at whatever detailed damages she intends to assert. If she has no provable damages, only speculation, would a trial judge allow the case to go to a jury or would a motion for judgment at the close of plaintiff's case for lack of proven damages prevail?

Surely there may be evidence Carnahan could present. But until things happen at a trial, who knows? It's a gamble.

As a general wrap-up, one might wonder why is Carnahan doing this. What benefit has she attained between serving her complaint and filing it as a public court document? Yes, she may convince a jury, she and counsel, and make some money via a jury award, but the involved people who already deem Carnahan a problematic person are not going to have opinions changed in her favor, by litigation. She got fired. By casting the deciding vote she attained a mid five figure settlement amount. 

Not enough? That was yesterday? 

She first has to defend her piece of paper against claims of false or improper procurement, and then has to convince regular people in the jury box that other people's speech rights were bargained away via a single signature of a person whose authority to bind the party by that signature appears questionable, much less having a power to compromise other people's civil rights. Right to rely seems a hurdle to Carnahan.

Why do it, why sue?

If the party and the lawyer who drafted the piece of paper have errors and omissions coverage, as might be expected, the lawsuit defense might be tendered, and if so the suit will not even be running the party's meter, but that of the coverage providers, while Carnahan will have to pay her own way, on speculation of a pot of gold at the rainbow's end.

It might settle short of trial. It might not. Carnahan already did attain one settlement. Short of filing suit, she had no chance of a further settlement, i.e., serving the papers did not alone result in any offer of settlement suitable to her intent and expectations. The beat goes on.