Thursday, April 16, 2009

Know your rights - relevant evidence - a right to be heard.

I have a show cause hearing I am required to attend, Thurs. 23 April, 9 am, Anoka County Courthouse, Cause Number 02-CV-09-2603.

I have subpoenaed witnesses, as is my right, and non-attendance or other non-compliance by one under subpoena has consequences under a Court's contempt powers.

The subject matter of the hearing is a matter of courthouse record, per the cause number. It is largely irrelevant to this post, which is more general than specific, but being both, and being about the rights of any individual feeling wrongly attacked in a court proceeding.

In calling witnesses to testify at a show cause hearing, the Court has discretion, depending on circumstances and judgment of the Judge hearing matters, to allow (when appropriate) extensive probative evidence of the kind permitted by these few mostly sequential rules of evidence (online, here) [note, bolding in the original, some italics added for emphasis]:

Rule 404. Character Evidence Not Admissible to Prove Conduct; Exceptions; Other Crimes

(a) Character evidence generally. Evidence of a person’s character or a trait of character is not admissible for the purpose of proving action in conformity therewith on a particular occasion, except:

(1) Character of accused. Evidence of a pertinent trait of character offered by an accused, or by the prosecution to rebut the same;

(2) Character of victim. Evidence of a pertinent trait of character of the victim of the crime offered by an accused, or by the prosecution to rebut the same, or evidence of a character trait of peacefulness of the victim offered by the prosecution in a homicide case to rebut evidence that the victim was the first aggressor.

[...]

(b) Other crimes, wrongs, or acts. Evidence of another crime, wrong, or act is not admissible to prove the character of a person in order to show action in conformity therewith. It may, however, be admissible for other purposes, such as proof of motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, or absence of mistake or accident. [...]


Rule 405. Methods of Proving Character

(a) Reputation or opinion. In all cases in which evidence of character or a trait of character of a person is admissible, proof may be made by testimony as to reputation or by testimony in the form of an opinion. On cross-examination, inquiry is allowable into relevant specific instances of conduct.

(b) Specific instances of conduct. In cases in which character or trait of character of a person is an essential element of a charge, claim, or defense, proof may also be made of specific instances of that person’s conduct.


Rule 406. Habit; routine Practice

Evidence of the habit of a person or of the routine practice of an organization, whether corroborated or not and regardless of the presence of eyewitnesses, is relevant to prove that the conduct of the person or organization on a particular occasion was in conformity with the habit or routine practice.


Rule 407. Subsequent Remedial Measures

When, after an injury or harm allegedly caused by an event, measures are taken which, if taken previously, would have made the event less likely to occur, evidence of the subsequent measures is not admissible to prove negligence, culpable conduct, a defect in a product, a defect in a product’s design, or a need for a warning or instruction. This rule does not require the exclusion of evidence of subsequent measures when offered for another purpose, such as proving ownership, control, or feasibility of precautionary measures, if controverted, or impeachment.


Rule 806. Attacking and Supporting Credibility of Declarant

When a hearsay statement, or a statement defined in Rule 801(d)(2)(C), (D), or (E), has been admitted in evidence, the credibility of the declarant may be attacked, and if attacked may be supported, by any evidence which would be admissible for those purposes if declarant had testified as a witness. Evidence of a statement or conduct by the declarant at any time, inconsistent with the declarant’s hearsay statement, is not subject to any requirement that the declarant may have been afforded an opportunity to deny or explain. If the party against whom a hearsay statement has been admitted calls the declarant as a witness, the party is entitled to examine the declarant on the statement as if under cross-examination.


I put that last item in, so that if, for example, a court record from another instance of litigation involving a party is introduced, that party can attack the character, motive, bona fides, etc., of the declarant - the person authoring or offering the document in the other proceeding, but not a witness in person in the underlying dispute.

However, as with all matters before a Judge, credibility is weighed in part by demanor and conduct, so that delicacy in using rules is important.

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Tonight's Ramsey Council Meeting - Case 11

The word respect got abused.

Respect has to be earned.

Respect is not what King Edward Longshanks got in Braveheart.

This group should see the film. See and understand it.

The woman who spoke at quarter to eleven nailed it. More people like her should run for office. She'd have had my vote, election time, but held back and was not on the ballot.

Monday, April 13, 2009

Is anyone else offended, even outraged, by this?

Strib, online today, reports:

Gophers won't return to basketball team next season
FROM NEWS SERVICES update: April 11, 2009 - 12:14 PM


Gophers men's basketball reserves Travis Busch and Kevin Payton will not return for their senior seasons, according to a release from the school. Their scholarships were not renewed by coach Tubby Smith.

"We are grateful for what Travis and Kevin brought to the University of Minnesota during their time on campus," Smith said. Smith needed two additional scholarships to accommodate a four-man incoming recruiting class.

It was bad enough seeing a basketball coach being the highest paid "faculty" at the U. of Minn., but now, that individual is releasing basketball talent, to take on more promising, more talented individuals.

But aren't these supposed to be "student-athletes" so that if there's no academic problems, there's no disciplinary problems, the coach is complimentary, then they can stay for their final year and boost the graduation rates for b-ball; but instead it's into the ashbin anyway? Isn't there something basically wrong in that?

There's no suggestion of malingering, inattentiveness, or playing under capability - only not playing well enough to subjectively please Coach Smith with better prospects in mind. Academically they apparently are fine, or the coach is not saying otherwise - he's saying nice while you were helpful, others promise to be more helpful.


BOTTOM LINE: Is this a professional athletic franchise, or a university?

______UPDATE______
An apology to Coach Smith and the Golden Gopher Basketball program.

The error is Strib's not mine. I had a nagging worry after posting, whether one key fact unmentioned cut one way or the other, so I went to the Golden Gopher website.

Here, the U.Minn. athletic department reports, and the Strib sportswriters, for whatever reasons they have did not think the opening paragraph of the team's news release was relevant:

University of Minnesota men's basketball head coach Tubby Smith and the Golden Gopher basketball program today announced that guards Travis Busch and Kevin Payton will forgo their final season of eligibility at the University of Minnesota. Both players are seniors academically and are on schedule to graduate this spring.


That puts the announcement in a favorable, not unfavorable light. The team graduation rate is enhanced, each of the young men can move on to his life's work, and Smith is praisworthy in working out a situation of extra elibibility not needed to graduate on time. I have no problem with the situation, except that Strib, given the Clem Haskins problems the program had, should have been more comprehensive in the online report. Unlike a print edition item, online fitting things on a page along with paid advertisement is not determinative in shortening a story.

The Strib story was shortened leaving an impression of jetisoned young men. It is hardly so. Again, the program is not at fault.

Thursday, April 09, 2009

Is the City of Ramsey's business listing reliable?


The listing is http://www.ci.ramsey.mn.us/Documents/Front%20page/businesslist012609.pdf. The image is p.9 of 10 pages, showing all listings beginning with a "T."

While firms such as Trilogy Construction are listed, one clear omission is Trott Brook Financial, see here and here.

I do not understand that discrepancy.

With one omission clearly shown, how reliable is the remainder, for listing those doing business in Ramsey?

Readers are invited to download the list and to indicate any errors they might note.

Prosecutorial Misconduct, Ted Stevens, and unfolding drama affecting the high and mighty. Would backlash happen if you or I were abusively targeted?

All indications are ex-Sen. Ted Stevens got a bum trial, factual disclosure he was entitled to was withheld, etc. That's great for a former senator, but does it (prosecutorial misconduct) happen to many others, with nary a hint of concern on the part of those who should ride herd on the conduct of subordinates? That's a question we all should consider, since any one of us can become a wrongful target of abusive official conduct in instigation, investigation or prosecution of a criminal charge - with lot less of a a "high and mighty" dimension, and without the high profile the Stevens situation commanded.

NYTimes has an excellent factual report, quoted here, but read the original to benefit from links:

Justice Dept. Moves to Void Stevens Case
By NEIL A. LEWIS - Published: April 1, 2009

WASHINGTON
— The Justice Department moved on Wednesday to drop all charges against former Senator Ted Stevens of Alaska, who lost his seat last year just days after being convicted on seven felony counts of ethics violations.

The case was one of the most high profile and bitterly fought in a string of corruption investigations into current and former members of Congress. But Justice Department lawyers told a federal court Wednesday that they had discovered a new instance of prosecutorial misconduct, on top of earlier disclosures that had raised questions about the way the case was handled, and asked that the convictions be voided.

The attorney general, Eric H. Holder Jr., said he would not seek a new trial.

The collapse of the Stevens case was a profound embarrassment for the Justice Department, and it raised troubling issues about the integrity of the actions of prosecutors who wield enormous power over people they investigate. Mr. Stevens’s case was handled by senior officials of the department’s Public Integrity Section, which handles official corruption cases.

Mr. Holder, himself a former prosecutor and judge, noted that the department’s Office of Professional Responsibility was conducting a review of the prosecutors’ conduct, raising the possibility that some of those who tried Mr. Stevens on ethics charges could themselves now face ethics charges.

Mr. Stevens said in a statement: “I always knew that there would be a day when the cloud that surrounded me would be removed. That day has finally come. It is unfortunate that an election was affected by proceedings now recognized as unfair.”

Mr. Stevens was charged in July with lying on Senate disclosure forms by concealing an estimated $250,000 worth of goods and services he received, mostly to renovate a chalet he owned in Alaska. Prosecutors said he had received the bulk of the goods and services from Bill Allen, a longtime friend who had made a fortune by providing services to Alaska’s booming oil industry.

But in their filing on Wednesday, government lawyers said they had recently learned that trial prosecutors had concealed from Mr. Stevens’s defense lawyers the notes from a 2008 interview with Mr. Allen that raised significant doubts about the charges. Among other things, Mr. Allen asserted in the interview that the work on the Stevens home was worth only about $80,000, they said.

Mr. Stevens’s lawyers argued during the trial that the senator had been unaware of the help he received from Mr. Allen and had not intentionally concealed anything. Mr. Allen, the prosecution’s chief witness, provided forceful testimony intended to demonstrate that Mr. Stevens had been fully aware of what he received and had even signaled that he wanted it concealed.

Mr. Holder said in a statement that “I have concluded that certain information should have been provided to the defense for use at trial.”

Mr. Stevens had faced an almost-certain prison term on the conviction. But Judge Emmet G. Sullivan had delayed imposing a sentence because he was considering motions by Mr. Stevens’s lawyers to throw out the conviction based on previous disclosures of prosecutorial misconduct. The judge repeatedly scolded prosecutors during the trial over a series of incidents in which they concealed information from defense lawyers.

Judge Sullivan recently ordered that some of the government lawyers involved be held in contempt of court, including the two top officials of the Public Integrity Section.

Judge Sullivan displayed his annoyance with the prosecutors’ conduct for the first time almost four weeks before Mr. Stevens was convicted. On Oct. 3, the judge almost declared a mistrial after discovering that prosecutors had not told the defense team about a different interview with Mr. Allen by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.

“How does the court have confidence that the Public Integrity Section has public integrity?” Judge Sullivan asked that day.

The chief prosecutor, Brenda Morris, apologized for her team’s mistakes. But she also called the errors careless, not purposeful.

But last month, an F.B.I. agent who had worked on the investigation disputed that characterization of events, accusing prosecutors and a fellow agent of willfully concealing evidence from Mr. Stevens’s lawyers.

The agent, Chad Joy, wrote in the complaint that he had “witnessed or learned of serious violations of policy, rules and procedures as well as possible criminal violations.”

Judge Sullivan ruled that Ms. Morris and two other prosecutors — William Welch and Patty Stemler — were in contempt of court after the Justice Department failed to produce documents the judge had requested to assess Mr. Joy’s complaint.


With that factual background as a basis, there is this from TPM:

A Critical Step to Improving Prosecutorial Accountability

This week, U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder dismissed the case against former Senator Ted Stevens of Alaska. Citing prosecutorial misconduct as the primary reason, the Justice Department determined that the fairness of the trial had been too damaged by government misconduct to proceed further.

The Stevens case had been marred by prosecutorial misconduct from the outset. Judge Emmett Sullivan repeatedly criticized prosecutors for failing to follow orders to provide evidence to the defense. In addition, prosecutorial misconduct at trial led Judge Sullivan to hold one of the prosecutors in contempt, and at one point instruct the jury to disregard some evidence presented by the prosecution.

The proper role of a prosecutor is not to simply seek convictions, but to see that justice is done. In pursuing a conviction against Stevens, prosecutors ignored their constitutional and ethical obligations to ensure a fair trial process. Holder rightly recognizes that there can be no justice when the fairness of a criminal proceeding is interrupted by government misconduct. The convictions against Stevens were obtained through the abuse of prosecutorial power and the wrongful suppression of evidence.


Likewise, the proper role of police investigation is to fairly attain facts to discern whether probable cause exists to believe a crime happened. Nobody has to talk to police, and it is unprofessional to quiz a targeted individual while holding any belief probable cause exists, without giving Miranda warnings - a safeguard all citizens are entitled to expect and demand. Police must themselves obey the law and the requirements it places on them - and an absence of Miranda warnings is equivalent to representing to a target individual that the investigator at the time believes there is a lack of probable cause, while making inquiry. TPM contines:

Unfortunately, the kind of prosecutorial misconduct that occurred in Steven's case is pervasive in our criminal justice system, at both the state and federal level. Withholding evidence is the most common type of prosecutorial misconduct. Making matters worse, prosecutors who engage in even the most egregious misconduct are rarely investigated or held accountable for abusing their power. Holder should be commended for taking a step in the right direction to hold prosecutors accountable for their actions in calling for an internal investigation in this case. It remains to be seen what will come of that investigation and how the prosecutors in Stevens case will be held accountable for their egregious abuses of power.

The vast majority of states have failed to enact effective safeguards designed to prevent misuse of prosecutorial power. Prosecutors are rarely reported to disciplinary authorities for acts of misconduct, and state bar associations rarely initiate disciplinary proceedings against prosecutors--civil practitioners are disciplined on a much greater scale than prosecutors. States should follow the example Holder set in the Stevens case by quickly taking actions to effectively respond to prosecutorial misconduct when it occurs.


Amen. Also, obviously, prosecutorial bosses, the Holders of this world at county and local levels should be sensitive to avoid compromising situations, such as, hypothetically, a county attorney sitting on a planning board rubber stamping questionale land dealings of another public official - how that other one uses power and office to accrue personal gain. Any prosecutor putting herself into such a situation should be questioning her own judgment and objectivity, then and later down the road. The TPM item concludes:

The Justice Project's upcoming publication, Improving Prosecutorial Accountability: A Policy Review, outlines the systemic problems that lead to prosecutorial misconduct and recommends reforms to improve prosecutorial accountability. For example, The Justice Project recommends jurisdictions adopt open-file discovery in criminal cases, which would largely eliminate the ability of prosecutors to withhold important evidence, as they did in the Stevens case. Further, The Justice Project also recommends jurisdictions establish prosecutorial review boards that would be responsible for investigating and sanctioning prosecutors who abuse their power.

Prosecutorial misconduct is costly and damaging to our criminal justice system, and Holder's actions this week recognize this. Indeed, prosecutorial misconduct plays a significant role in many wrongful convictions that have sent innocent people to prison while the true perpetrator remained free. Eric Holder should be applauded for sending the right message to all prosecutors that such abuses of power will not be tolerated.

John F. Terzano is President of The Justice Project, a nonpartisan organization that works to increase fairness and accuracy in the criminal justice system.


The same idea, from another corner of the nation, and from a Duke University professor experienced in the publicly shameful situation of wrongful convictions, here, telling some tuths as they are but should not be:

One System, Two Realities

The United States has one of the best criminal justice systems on earth; in practice, however, there are two systems. One system, the one that tried former Senator Ted Stevens, seeks justice. The other system, the one to which the public is largely indifferent, is the one in which the kind of misconduct that freed Mr. Stevens is both common and tolerated.

We learn about the American criminal justice in middle-school civics classes. The system is an adversarial one. Both the state and the criminal defendant are represented by equally well-qualified advocates. A judge presides over the trial to make sure both sides play by the rules. If either side commits serious errors, the judge may stop the proceedings or overturn the conviction; "it is better that ten guilty men go free than one innocent man be wrongly convicted."

Our system is also democratic. Trials are public affairs. Every defendant is presumed innocent until a jury of his peers convict him; he is not required to testify at trial and jurors may not infer guilt from his failure to do so.

The Duke Innocence Project investigates the cases of poor and minority prisoners in North Carolina who have nothing in common with the Duke lacrosse players. In case after case, law students are surprised at how little evidence it took to convict the prisoner. And students are dismayed by the widespread indifference of the police, prosecutors, judges, defense lawyers, the North Carolina Attorney General, and the public to the routine misconduct of some prosecutors and police officers and to the possibility than some of these prisoners may be innocent.

When Reade Seligmann, one of the Duke lacrosse players, was exonerated, he said: "This entire experience has opened my eyes up to a tragic world of injustice I never knew existed. If it is possible for law enforcement officials to systematically railroad us with no evidence whatsoever, it is frightening to think what they could do to those who do not to have the resources to defend themselves."


No citizen in a civilized nation should be indifferent to such "frightening" reality. Those with resources have a level of "justice" available that those lacking resources in turn lack. It is known as the "deep pocket" having the advantage; the modern day Golden Rule, "Those having the gold make their own rules."

Think about it. Think about that hypothetical county prosecutor, compromising herself in a way that was unnecessary but politically expedient, easy, and appealingly gratifying at the time. It is a system failing to work if Miranda warnings are ignored, if cops infer "probable cause" from a target person's unwillingness to be quizzed, if cops and prosecutors withhold notice of what's been alleged by whom, etc. It is a system failing to work properly from a host of such things that make us less as a nation than we could and should aim to be.

Huffington Post poses similar concerns, here, and take some of the premises with a grain of salt:

After the dark days at the Department of Justice under President Bush, not surprisingly integrity seems to have returned under President Obama and Eric Holder. But how far will that integrity go? Will Holder be willing to tackle more subtle and elusive forms of prosecutorial misconduct? Will Holder insist that his prosecutors staunchly obey their oath "to seek justice," rather than simply and relentlessly striving for high conviction rates?

There are two areas of rampant prosecutorial misconduct that Holder should address. First, prosecutors routinely suborn perjury by coercing defendants--particularly white-collar defendants--into pleading guilty even when they may not be guilty. Second, prosecutors arbitrarily invoke a statute that is so vague, so poorly defined, and so ubiquitous that any man, woman, and child could become a convicted felon.

This may come as a surprise, but Abramoff was the victim of both forms of prosecutorial misconduct.

Abramoff may have pushed the envelope in his efforts to lobby vigorously for his clients, but he did not believe he was guilty of the serious criminal activities to which he pleaded guilty. So this begs the question. Why did he plead guilty if he did not believe he was guilty, and if in fact he may not have been guilty?

Herein lies the insidiousness and scope of prosecutorial misconduct. First, the prosecutors threatened that if Abramoff didn't play ball, they would not rest until they had found him guilty of some offense, for which he would be sent to a maximum-security prison with violent offenders for thirty years. Furthermore, Abramoff knew that the prosecutors had unlimited funds and resources, whereas he certainly did not. But they then made him an offer he couldn't refuse. They told Abramoff that if he pleaded guilty to whatever crimes they told him to plead guilty to, and if he cooperated in their ongoing investigation, then he would receive a much-reduced sentence, spent in a relatively cushy prison camp. This would also guarantee the prosecutors a conviction without facing the risk of a trial by jury. Perhaps Abramoff's fate would have been radically different if he had had Brendan Sullivan Jr. as his defense counsel. Instead, the terrified Abramoff quietly committed perjury by agreeing to plead guilty, something he couldn't dare admit now, because he could then be openly charged with perjury.

In November 2007, The New York Times reported that nearly 30% of convicted and imprisoned rapists and murderers later exonerated by DNA evidence had pleaded guilty. Why did they plead guilty when they were innocent? Because prosecutors terrified them into pleading guilty. This is the kind of prosecutorial misconduct that must stop.


As a wrap-up, Politico, warning us that the freedoms we enjoy are not automatic, but that people in positions of power can do good and bad things,

The Ted Stevens case this week is only the latest example — one in which Judge Emmet Sullivan threw out Stevens’ conviction and launched a criminal contempt investigation against a half-dozen federal prosecutors Tuesday, calling their actions “shocking and disturbing.”

Attorney General Eric Holder announced Tuesday he’s replacing the head of the office that investigates misconduct by Justice Department attorneys, just a day after Sullivan publicly complained about the unit’s slow pace.

But other federal judges, too, are complaining about the work done by Justice Department prosecutors.

• Federal Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly recently removed a Justice Department lawyer from a Guantanamo detainee case for flouting several deadlines, then lambasted his supervisor for submitting a “shockingly revisionist” sequence of events to the court.

• In Miami last month, federal Judge Alan Gold complained of "flagrant violations" by prosecutors who did not disclose the existence of secret recordings of a defense lawyer for a doctor charged with prescription fraud.
See also

* Pentagon preps for economic warfare
* Parental rights: The new wedge issue
* U.S. could join direct talks with Iran

• Another federal judge in Washington, John Bates, last year cited a failure to turn over evidence as he ordered a new trial for a man convicted of illegal business dealings with Iran. Bates said he had “grave concerns” about the government’s actions, which “severely prejudiced” the defendant’s fair trial rights.

• And in a separate Gitmo case, Sullivan also lashed out at the government, vowing that “someone’s going to pay a price” for withholding evidence.

What’s remarkable about several of those cases is that judges – usually loath to interfere in the mechanics of the prosecution or the defense — took the dramatic step of removing Justice Department lawyers, or simply throwing out verdicts in cases that began during the prior administration.

This repeated criticism delivered to DOJ attorneys suggests they are facing a credibility gap, particularly before judges in the Capital—and perhaps elsewhere in the country as well—that could have profound effects in a variety of other cases.


It's a long screed. But think about it, please. Freedoms we presume are inviolable may only be so if we insist that they be so, regardless of the pressures brought to bear toward compromise or capitulation.

I don't know about Abramoff and that line of analysis, but I know I will try to never be steamrolled by powerful or well-placed people, making wrongful allegations against me. We all should stand up for our rights, for what's right.

Wednesday, April 08, 2009

Some favorite Minnesota cases.

First, Stead-Bowers v. Langley, 636 N.W.2d 334 (Minn. Ct. App. 2001), in which the tort or malicious prosecution was reaffirmed as requiring that an actual criminal proceeding be initiated, and that mere filing of a police complaint is insufficient cause upon which to base a malicious prosecution action. In that case one city council member sued other city officials, complaining she'd been wronged. Her case was thrown out.

In Dunham v. Roer, 708 N.W.2d 552 (Minn.App. 2006) review denied, March 28, 2006; there was much ado about nothing, including whether one party called the other a "slut." The court held that there was insufficient basis for an allegation that a Minnesota harassment statute was unconstitutionally overbroad and vague or to be read as so overbraod as to infringe on protected free speech.

As to the "slut" terminology in Dunham, see, Bebo v. Delander, 632 N.W.2d 732 (Minn. Ct. App. 2001), where calling someone an "asshole" is not defamatory as it is not truly an allegation of fact. It is metaphor, I suppose.

Truth is always an absolute defense to defamation allegations, and there is much constitutional law on what is a "public figure" and a "quasi-public figure" and in the Internet age, you go on facebook, etc., is that making you a public figure; you post things such as Flickr photos without any "all rights reserved" language and advertise the Flickr photos on a blog, are you making yourself a public figure, or at least a quasi public figure, per New York Times v. Sullivan? Then, even with duly copyrighted material, what is fair use?

What is opinion, musing over possible questions, or such, short of any actual factual contention?

Indeed, the law is quite elastic, and that's why cases are not always settled but sometimes go to trial. If the law were iron-clad certain; and motives were not circumstantially vague, then much uncertainty in the system would not exist.

But the law also is fundamentally reasonable. If you have a beef, try to get it satisfied short of extreme measures - the law expects that of you.

That is one reason why I post an email address on the sidebar.

Although I do not feel I ever have posted anything improper; that address is always there; where the simple act of seeking a retraction and giving reasons why one is due, is always available. It is the reasonable step that should always be pursued as a first measure, if one has a measured mind (free of emotional extremism severe enough to trump such a singularly reasonable and immediate thing as seeking a correction or change before flying off the handle).

That's how I feel reasonable people should operate.

It is a basic core principle that I hold dear to how I feel civil society should function. Contacting me if ever a person feels wronged by anything I put on this blog is hoped for. Wouldn't you want that in my place?

It's to be expected.

______FURTHERMORE_______
Malicious prosecution claims can be collaterally estopped, where, utimately, “collateral estoppel claims are not determined by measuring the manner in which each party conducted litigation, but rather according to the opportunity to address an issue.” Williamson v. Guentzel, 584 N.W.2d 20, 23-24 (Minn. App. 1998), review denied (Minn. Nov. 24, 1998). One thing interesting about that case is its referencing near the end,

Appellant also contends that summary judgment was improperly granted to Guentzel because he was liable for procuring Fetzer's initiation of the underlying lawsuit against appellant. As support for this proposition, appellant cites Restatement (Second) of Torts § 674 (1965) (one who “takes an active part in the initiation, continuation, or procurement” of civil suit against another liable if suit was wrongful).

Restatements of the law are persuasive authority only and are not binding unless specifically adopted in Minnesota by statute or case law. See Mahowald v. Minnesota Gas Co., 344 N.W.2d 856, 860 (Minn. 1984) (adopting a portion of the Restatement (Second) of Torts, but rejecting other sections). Appellant has failed to cite any authority demonstrating that Minnesota has adopted section 674 of the Restatement. Because the propositions of section 674 would not establish a claim against respondent Guentzel, we need not decide whether the section governs Minnesota law.

Liability for procurement under the Restatement is not established by merely advising parties or supplying information, but only arises when a party induces a third party to take action either by “insisting” or “urging” that a suit be filed or continued. Id. cmt. c (incorporating Restatement § 655 cmt. c (1965), which specifies that liability is not imposed on one who testifies voluntarily in the prosecution of an action, but is limited to those who insist or urge initiation or continuation of lawsuit).


What that implies, aside from and beyond the facts of that case, is that one can get into trouble instigating and promoting another to initiate or continue a wrongful lawsuit, and this arguably could apply if one spouse causes the other to indulge in wrongful and groundless litigation, or "procures" such actions, "liability for procurement" being the Court's language - which means that separate property of both spouses can in certain situations be put at risk via one spouse's malicious litigation and the other's facilitation of it.

______UPDATE______
Another favorite, unpublished but online and a 2009 case, State v. Selnick, which shows the kind of misconduct prosecutors should never get away with but which is a taint on justice that judges are too prone to overlook as harmless error. It is far from that. It is fundamental. You don't ever have to talk to cops if you do not want to, and that's irrelevant to criminal guilt and questions of probable cause to infer a criminal offense happened.

What's interesting to the blogsphere, Minn. Stat. Sect. 690.749, subd. 7, has been around since enactment of the statutory section; 1993 Minn. Laws, ch.326, art. 2, Sect.22. Without that legislative intent clear from the outset that protected speech such as blogsphere political discourse is not to be chilled; the remainder of the statute would be hopelessly unconstitutional by vagueness and more importantly, overbreadth. The legislature knew what it was doing in forcefully articulating a free speech constitutional exception to a statute on harassment. Some judges might have a hard time realizing that, some over-zealous and abusive prosecutors might also, but the exception is there for its purpose.

Michele Bachmann - fiddling while Rome burns.

Minnesota Independent, Andy Birkey reporting today online, says:

Bachmann’s district has Minnesota’s highest foreclosure rates

Foreclosures have hit Minnesota’s economy hard, leading to a debate among policymakers over how best to provide relief to the state’s families.

But a Minnesota Independent analysis of foreclosure data from across the state reveals that the crisis is worst where congressional representation is doing the least to address the issue.

Foreclosure rates were calculated using data from Housing Link, a non-partisan Minneapolis-based housing nonprofit, along with county sheriffs’ sale records and estimated numbers of households in 2007 from the state demographer’s office. Congressional district rates were determined using city- and township-level data where boundaries did not follow county lines. The calculations used are the same as those spelled out in the state statute for determining foreclosure rates.

The data show that the northern suburbs and exurbs of the Twin Cities have seen the bulk of the foreclosures in 2008, and the southern suburbs have experienced a high number as well.

While much of the crisis is centralized in an area covering two congressional districts, a search of the congressional record reveals that the representatives in those districts are dealing with the crisis very differently. Rep. Michele Bachmann has voted against all but one measure aimed at foreclosure relief, while Rep. Keith Ellison in the neighboring district has supported or introduced more than a dozen bills to address the issue.

Trouble in the Sixth

Just to the north of the Twin Cities, the 6th district, represented by Republican Rep. Michele Bachmann, had the most foreclosures of any of Minnesota’s eight congressional districts, with an estimated 5,227 in 2008. Her district also had the highest rate of foreclosures as a percentage of households, at 1.80 percent, nearly that of the city of Minneapolis at 1.85 percent.

The situation was similar in 2007, when, according to a Housing Link study, Bachmann’s district had a higher foreclosure rate than the rest of Minnesota and the rest of the country.

But Bachmann’s record in Congress is not one of a representative whose district faces such a crisis. Bachmann hasn’t authored or sponsored any legislation to assist homeowners facing foreclosure, but she has co-sponsored 14 bills to restrict abortions and five to promote Christianity in government.

Bachmann voted against five key foreclosure relief bills, including the Mortgage Reform and Anti-Predatory Lending Act, which would set standards for mortgages and reduce predatory lending, and the Neighborhood Stabilization Act, which would provide funds for buying and rehabilitating foreclosed properties in affected neighborhoods. She also opposed the Expanding American Homeownership Act, which allows more people to qualify for FHA-backed mortgages, and the Expand and Preserve Home Ownership Through Counseling Act, which aims to improve financial literacy. Bachmann additionally voted against the Housing and Economic Recovery Act of 2008, a law signed by President Bush that contained many provisions to assist struggling homeowners and also the only one of the bills to become law.

Before the first four of these measures reached the House floor, Bachmann opposed them in the House Financial Services Committee. She also voted against the FHA Housing Stabilization and Homeownership Rentention Act of 2008, which did not receive a floor vote. The bill would have provided mortgage refinancing assistance to struggling families and expanded FHA loan programs.

Bachmann further offered an amendment to block increased funding for HOPE for Homeowners, a Department of Housing and Urban Development program that helps families facing foreclosure to refinance their mortgages.

When Congress was debating strategies to assist families facing foreclosure, Bachmann called those homeowners “irresponsible.”

“Now, we can debate whether this is the right thing to do as it may seem that you’re rewarding the irresponsible while punishing those who have been playing by the rules,” she said in Febraury. “When President Obama released his plan … to prevent home foreclosures, the point he wanted to get across to everyone watching was that money from folks who have been making their payments on time will not just be handed over to those folks who got in over their heads and bought a house they knew they couldn’t afford.”

Those homes that residents of the 6th district couldn’t afford had a median value of $239,000, according to the 2007 American Community Survey, just above the national median of $229,000. Prices have likely declined considerably since the 2007 survey.

Bachmann’s office did not respond to a request for comment on the foreclosure data or her voting record.

While foreclosure rates are nearly as high in the neighboring 5th Congressional District, Democratic Rep. Keith Ellison has been working to address the crisis.

The 5th district, encompassing Minneapolis and its surrounding suburbs, has the second-highest foreclosure rate in the state, with an estimated 4,413 foreclosures in 2008 at a rate of 1.63 percent.

Ellison’s efforts to address the foreclosure crisis have been noticed on a national scale.

He authored a bill that gives renters 90 days notice when a housing unit goes into foreclosure and allow them to finish their lease.

“I think it’s in the best interest of the banks to keep people in these [housing] units,” Ellison told the Independent. “These empty buildings create nuisances for crime, they get vandalized. While they sit empty, people come in and steal copper piping and it creates a risk for fire.”

The New York Times editorial board hailed Ellison’s bill. “This legislation would be good for renting families, which have been unfairly penalized by this crisis,” wrote the Times. “It would also help to stabilize heavily foreclosed neighborhoods by keeping buildings occupied and alive in areas that might otherwise become ghost towns.”


The article details more of Ellison's responsible effort. Have a look.

I certainly hope that redistricting eliminates Bachmann's Sixth, putting her home in the same district as Kline's so they can dog-fight over one single piece of meat, and that she fails in any intervening election attempt because, if I understand things correctly, the cushy pension does not vest until five years in either house of Congress has been accrued. If that's so, may she fall short and have to live on by her wits, such as they are.

_______UPDATE_______
Ask yourself, with all the merger-acquisition, new ownership and control of Countrywide, changes of that sort - when the dust settles who do you figure will end up controlling an inordinate amount of regular low and mid-end housing in the nation? Who owns and has aquired what? When and on what terms? How do such reorganizations affect the first and most major question - when the dust settles? Also, who will be buying and become housed in such situations, by rental or purchase?