Thursday, November 17, 2022

Asa Hutchinson. You may ask, "Who?"

 You might find the answer unambiguous, but would the answer inspire?

First, Real Clear Politics:

Former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson (R) said on PBS's 'Firing Line with Margaret Hoover' that former President Donald Trump's influence has diminished and it is time for the Republican party to have a "post-Trump future."

"The election reinforced my thinking that if we're going to win, we have to have common-sense conservatives," Hutchinson said. "We have to have those that can appeal to independents, that can actually bring people together and that can win in November,  [...]"

[red highlight added] Okay, hat in the ring. Is he the type of man who can sufficiently distinguish himself from Trump and from DeSantis, or not? Can he offer that sizzling difference the nation yearns for?

.......................................................

Hutchinson has a Wikipedia page, disclosing:

 Hutchinson took office as [Arkansas] governor on January 13, 2015.

On November 16, 2015, Hutchinson said that he would block all Syrian refugees from entering the state in response to the November 2015 Paris attacks.[23]

Under Hutchinson, Arkansas resumed executions in 2017 after having executed no one since 2005.[24][25][26] In 2021, DNA testing on the murder weapon and a bloody shirt at the scene of the crime did not match Ledell Lee, who was convicted and executed for murder.[27] Hutchinson defended Lee's execution, saying, "the DNA findings released today do not present any conclusive evidence to undermine [Lee's guilty verdict]."[27]

As governor, Hutchinson implemented work requirements for Medicaid enrollees. As a result, by December 2018, almost 17,000 Arkansans had lost their Medicaid health insurance, with reapplication available in the new calendar year.[28]

In February 2019, Hutchinson signed a bill into law that would criminalize abortion in the event Roe v. Wade is overturned.[29] On March 9, 2021, he signed SB6, a near-total abortion bill, into law. [...] 

In 2015, Hutchinson signed into law legislation that would prohibit localities from extending civil rights protections to LGBT individuals.[31] At the time, Arkansas was among states that allowed discrimination in the workplace, housing and business on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation.[32] In March 2021, Hutchinson signed into law legislation that would allow doctors to refuse non-emergency medical treatment to LGBT people based on moral objection.[33] In April 2021, he vetoed a bill that would make it illegal for transgender minors to receive gender-affirming medication or surgery,[34] calling it "a vast government overreach".[35] The state legislature later overrode his veto.[36]

In August 2021, Hutchinson signed bills into law that prohibited businesses and government facilities from requiring proof of COVID-19 vaccination for staff and customers to enter facilities.[37] While Arkansas was experiencing a wave of COVID-19 cases, he also signed a bill into law that prohibited state and local officials from enacting mask mandates.[38] He later said he regretted doing so.[38] In December 2021, Hutchinson praised President Joe Biden's COVID policies and thanked Biden for his efforts to "get the vaccinations out" and "depoliticizing" the federal COVID response.[39][40] In January 2022, Hutchinson encouraged large businesses to not comply with the Biden administration's vaccine requirements.[41]

Hutchinson demanded that Republicans who tried to overturn the 2020 presidential election and spread Trump's "Big Lie" about the election not be put in positions of leadership.[42] He also accused Trump of dividing the party and said his election conspiracies were "recipe for disaster".[43][44] On February 5, 2022, Hutchinson and U.S. Senator Lisa Murkowski condemned the Republican National Committee's censure of Representatives Adam Kinzinger and Liz Cheney for their support of and participation on the House Select Committee tasked with investigating the January 6 United States Capitol attack.[45] When asked in May 2022, Hutchinson said he supported Doug Mastriano in the 2022 Pennsylvania gubernatorial election;[46] Mastriano denies the results of the 2020 election, and said if elected governor he might certify Pennsylvania's electoral votes only if the Republican presidential nominee wins.[47]

Personal life

[...]  Hutchinson's son Asa Hutchinson III has been arrested multiple times for driving offenses, including arrests in 2019, 2018, and 2016 for DWI and an arrest for possession of a controlled substance at a music festival in 2016.[49] [...]

Previous to Hutchinson being governor, Wikipedia describes his earlier career. Check it out unless you feel you've seen enough.

There is Trump. Aside from Trump, there is DeSantis.

As an alternative to either of those two, should Asa Hutchinson's candidacy be taken seriously, and where would it place the Republican party, if taken seriously?

Consider the question in the context, there is Mike Pence. Who we know better than we know Hutchinson.


Well, it is the NY Times posting, but from it, this extended quote, "A growing chorus of Republican officials, lawmakers and activists blame the former president for their failure to regain control of the Senate and for what will be a narrow margin in the House. The scope of the Republican losses has prompted some of his allies to publicly voice complaints they have long kept private about the former president’s ability to win the White House. For those who have been more vocal, their concerns have morphed into far more direct attacks as they try to seize what they see as a chance to move past Mr. Trump and embrace a new class of party leaders."

Link. What is amusing, paragraphs directly following the headline quote-

At an annual gathering of Republican governors in Orlando, donors and lobbyists mingled with governors past, present and future while weighing ways to wrest Mr. Trump from the party’s base. Their main complaint was not over policy or even style, but losses the party has taken since Mr. Trump won the White House in 2016.

Gov. Kristi Noem of South Dakota, a Republican often mentioned as a potential 2024 candidate, said she did not believe Mr. Trump offered “the best chance” for the party in 2024.

“If we narrow our focus there, then we’re not talking to every single American,” Ms. Noem said in an interview as she sat across a mahogany table from her political adviser, Corey Lewandowski, who served as campaign manager for an early portion of Mr. Trump’s 2016 bid. “Our job is not just to talk to people who love Trump or hate Trump. Our job is to talk to every single American.”

Representative Mo Brooks of Alabama, a former Trump ally who spoke at the Jan. 6, 2021, rally that preceded the attack on the Capitol, put it more bluntly in a phone interview: “In 2020, there was no other option. In 2024 we will have candidates who are vastly superior and will do much, much better competing against the Democrat nominee than the loser Donald Trump has proven himself to be.”

Stuff there. Mo Brooks, did Trump help or hinder his reelection? Interested readers might want to look that up via web search.

Then, Republican Governors convening in Florida. 

Who does that bring to mind? Florida? A guy not quoted in the Times analysis.

Kristi Noem. Sorensen at Bluestem Prairie keeps an eye on South Dakota politics as well as on Minnesota, and she expands on that NYT reference to Noem. Sorensen's most recent post, 

The mahogany table of destiny; or, Noem in Florida, closer to Lewandowski than Trump 

No quote. Readers can simply follow the link and read Sorensen's insights and thougths. Well, one late in the item quote to whet the appetite.

Bluestem will be so cynical as to speculate that while we believe Governor Noem is entirely loyal to her husband, her connections with advisors are pure business and pragmatic. As for  her alignment with former President Trump, we South Dakotans should simply check our weathervanes and wind turbines to see which way the wind blows.

Noem is ambitious. Or that seems to be what Sorensen is suggesting. Ambition can move weathervanes, and with 2024 looming, what might Noem's ambitions entail?

A spot on the 2024 ticket? Top of that ticket? Noem?

Let Sorensen tell her story her way. Just remember Ron of Florida looms large, even this early. When people get to see more of who Ron has been and is, shifting can arise.

LAST: That last part of the headline, "... chance to move past Mr. Trump and embrace a new class of party leaders." Perhaps it should say "a new group" since same old - more of the same might be the appearance to many. Faces change. Habits, actions and embraced policy changes less. Cory Lewandowski in a way is a bridge to the present unchanging from the past. In the field of opportunity, it's plowing time again?

________UPDATE_______

As to Big Ron in Florida, he's pushed some real chickenshit stuff about former felon voting and it can, by intimidation, disenfranchise eligible voters. The Crabgrass hope is it will come around to bite him in the ass, for being an ass.

Wednesday, November 16, 2022

An interesting post for Republicans in Minnesota, Gary Gross, on the midterms, critical of some politicians' performance.

https://libertyprosperityblog.blogspot.com/2022/11/mitch-mcconnell-rick-scott-donald-trump.html

Being unfamiliar with what Gary is highlighting, his item speaks for itself, should readers be interested. A link. No quote. 


For this, going to Breitbart as a start seems appropriate. The post is offered as also having an appropriate wrap-up.

 Strib reports the same thing, per a Jill Covin Nov. 15 AP feed. HOOOWEVVVER, Breitbart headlines its homepage in fashion today. 

By screenshot, then  quote -

Quote -

"Despite the outcome of the Senate, we cannot lose hope—and we must all work hard for a gentleman and a great person by the name of Herschel Walker,” Trump continued. “He was an incredible athlete and he’ll be an even better senator. We elected a group of very talented America First leaders who will be stars in our party for many years to come. In the popular vote, another thing that’s not discussed, for the House, Republicans won 5 million more votes—the largest margin in many, many years—over the Democrats. Five million more votes.”

National Review. 

..................................................

A while ago, if recollection is correct, this item was linked to in posting long since scrolled into Crabgrass history. Hence it is given again as a link, as a wrap-up to this post. It is about a pair of kindred souls.

Read it or don't.


Let us reason together. [UPDATED]

For this we are to sacrifice patient-physician privacy, privacy in general, because an old document never mentions "privacy" (while neither mentioning "the unborn").


Wishing I had the link to the original, the image got saved, the link - no.

__________UPDATE__________ 

Today, after writing this post, I read writing in Strib about abortion from a wholly separate dimension - one unique to women, a stand-up exegesis of self examination and explanation by one intent to talk about the experience of her having an abortion. As a comedy routine.

"In my mind, it's somebody saying, 'Omigod, how could that possibly be funny or enjoyable?'" she told me. "Like, who could possibly want an hour about that?"

The twist is that her show is about much more than the abortion Leiby had three years ago. It's a meditation on birth control, sex education, women's health care, periods and the stigma against women who are childless by choice. But it's light, observational comedy, with lots of jokes and laughs, intended to humanize the experience of abortion.

And what a moment in history to broaden the conversation. Weeks after she debuted her off-Broadway show in April, a Supreme Court leak foretold its decision overturning Roe vs. Wade.

Now, fresh on the heels of midterm elections shaped by women voters defending their right to abortion, [Alison] Leiby (LIE-bee) is bringing her show to the Parkway Theater in Minneapolis on Friday. When she talks about her abortion, she recalls that day vividly, including the panic that she felt over what to wear. These are the mundane details about abortion that you don't hear in today's supercharged political environment.

[...] Here's more from my talk with Leiby, edited for length and clarity.

Q: What about abortion is funny?

A: Nothing and everything. When it's just this vague concept of a right or a freedom, and one often associated with trauma, it gets hard to joke about abortion. I think it's much more challenging than speaking from personal experience and being authentic: Well, here's how I felt, and then this happened. That just makes it a lot easier for people to get out of their own way with what they think about the topic, and just kind of listen and enjoy.

Q: It sounds like what you're trying to do is normalize this procedure.

A: Absolutely. We hear a lot of the narratives that get the most amplification when we talk about abortion, rightfully. You hear about victims of assault, incest and rape. We need abortion for all those things. But we also need abortion rights for people who find out they're pregnant and don't want to be pregnant — and that's the end of the story. We don't talk about those stories as much, and we need to include them in the fight for reproductive freedom.

Q: Abortion is often discussed as something that's deeply traumatizing for the woman. Did you feel that way after the procedure?

A: I did not at all, which is another reason I wanted to start working on the show. I had no trauma around the way I got pregnant, nor around my decision to have an abortion, nor around my access to an ability to have one. So for me, it was this completely non-emotional journey. But we're taught that it is this heavy, dark thing. And then the only real emotions I had around my abortion were that I felt bad that I didn't feel bad enough.

Q: Is it scary to talk about something so polarizing and vulnerable while on stage?

A: It's easy to talk to a group of people who came to see someone talking about abortion. What's much harder to talk about is not wanting to have kids. There's my own emotional journey with finally accepting that. I talk a lot about the experience of being child-free, and how every part of our culture is pressuring women to have families and give birth, as if that is how you bring value to society.

[...] If you go

"Oh God, A Show About Abortion," 8 p.m. Fri., Parkway Theater, 4814 Chicago Av. S., Mpls. Tickets: $25-$35 at theparkwaytheater.com.

This is a fairly extended excerpt of Yuen's item, to capture much of the mood and content of the presentation, yet where much more original content holds Yuen's post together. Readers are urged to follow the link and read the entire Yuen post. 

A hope is that with the presentation detail - place, time and ticket - Crabgrass readers who might have missed the Strib item may be clued to attend if learning of it here and intrigued.

FURTHER: Childlessness: With birthrates down, the making of a decision to go childless needs discussion. When made, the Crabgrass opinion is that it should be a decision free of any grumbling about paying school taxes for the children of others because the financing and governing of public education is not primarily for us as individuals but for our society collectively needing a steady, educated populace to make representative democracy work with continuity and without co-option by despotically inclined people or factions. 

Long sentence, but that's okay. At least the sentence states a hope.


Tuesday, November 15, 2022

Emmer in the news. [UPDATED]

Strib, beginning:

After divisive midterms, U.S. Rep. Tom Emmer tries for new leadership role

The Minnesotan is asking fellow Republicans to make him the next House majority whip.  

WASHINGTON – U.S. Rep. Tom Emmer's ability to win a powerful House leadership role could rest on whether his fellow Republicans see the midterms as a success or a failure.

With Republicans favored to win back control of the chamber, the Minnesotan who led the House GOP's campaign arm is running this week to become the coveted majority whip. Yet that majority could come by a relatively small number of seats instead of the sizable wave of Republican wins the right had hoped to see.

"The bottom line is, we flipped the House and we're now going to be a check on Joe Biden and the Democrats' one-party rule," Emmer told reporters the day after the election.

His bid to become the third-highest ranking House Republican is the latest political move for the lawyer, former state legislator, governor candidate and radio talk show host from Delano. But as legislators made their way back to Capitol Hill on Monday, control of the House had yet to officially be called.

[...]

Emmer RNCC leadership moves were not responsible for any strong Dem election results this November. GOTV among the young was. 

And GOTV among the young can keep Dem prospects sound as long as the inner party does not fuck up by taking the young for granted as having no other option in two-party politics.

The inner party can show wisdom of moving its agenda toward what the people want. Progressive goals - and Sam Alito and henchpersons also - energized things where a return to cynicism is likely - because Dem inner party business as usual is likely. 

Flat learning curve is the worry, but if the Republicans run Trump again, the Dems can get by with a flat learning curve because running Trump again would show a flatter learning curve. 

DeSantis; more progressiveness is a necessity. And a showing of abortion attention remaining strong and not an "issue" to be trotted out for elections, then between elections to languish while the politicians play other politics of the moment.

Dumbness among Dem inner party types can boost the Republicans. Unlikely wisdom would have an opposite effect. Clinton mistakes still stand strong.

We wait. We see.

________UPDATE________

Emmer elected House Republican whip, per Strib

 Emmer's promotion follows his work chairing the National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC) for the last two cycles. Republicans cut into Democrats' majority during the 2020 election, even as Donald Trump lost the presidency. And last week's midterms gave them the chance to benefit from recent election trends and seeming political momentum.

Republicans came into Tuesday likely to hold the House by a relatively small number of seats. That reality loomed over Emmer's run for the whip job on Capitol Hill this week.

"A lot of people appreciate the fact that he stuck with the NRCC job for the last four years. There were expectations of [larger] numbers, but the fact of the matter is we're going to be in the majority," Minnesota GOP U.S. Rep. Brad Finstad, who supported Emmer for whip, said ahead of the vote. "We can armchair quarterback, should it have been 20 more seats, 30 more seats, whatever it may be, but he delivered."

While this won't be the 230- or 240-seat majority that Republicans wanted, GOP U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler of Pennsylvania, an Emmer ally, said Monday it was even more imperative that Emmer be chosen as the whip.

"With a thin majority, you're going to need a whip who has the nuance, who has the understanding of the difference between a deep-red district and a swing blue district, and there's no other candidate in this race besides Tom Emmer that brings that nuance and understanding to the table," Reschenthaler said.

Emmer and nuance being used together in the same sentence seems strange when thinking back to the Michel Bachmann days, and Emmer's unsuccessful run for Guv.

Final Strib paragraph - 

"I'm willing to work with Tom and Republicans on good policy for the country," Minnesota U.S. Rep. Angie Craig, a swing-district Democrat the House Republicans' campaign arm tried and failed to defeat, said Tuesday ahead of the GOP leadership elections. "But what I don't want to see, and I fear their caucus doing this, is two years of 'Let's just scream from the mountaintops and focus on investigations.'"

Is Craig specifically thinking of Emmer re that fear, or thinking of her knowledge of the Republican House caucus after having served time in DC?

BOTTOM LINE: Emmer is whip with that thin Republican majority, his job being to knock heads together and keep the caucus on message. We hope Craig is wrong about the message. Emmer has moved beyond any level of politics this Blog would have ever anticipated. Let's watch. With 2024 anticipation, Trump and DeSantis and whoever, each caucus member has free speech rights.

 

Do you trust this promise? Do you see the ambiguity and want to read it differently than what I'd hope it means? Steve Timmer does not expect a Jim Schultz quiet and firm retirement from politics. My guess, having built name recognition leads to something. Likely with a different support network of people, since a well-founded campaign violation complaint remains pending, and Schultz has talent enough for a learning curve, as well as for saying, "It was my first test of politics, and I relied upon seasoned professionals." Similar to Trump saying, "I relied on what the lawyers said, or what I believed what they were saying meant."

 For posterity, this screen capture pair - first, from the Schultz Facebook page, a capture from the promise/paragraph to the end of the post. Then, the full concession statement, naming several names - with the promise/paragraph at the end of the statement:


 

https://jimformnag.com/schultz-statement-on-the-election-results/

The operative words, with ambiguity, " . . . I’ll return to the private sector but will never stop fighting for the people of Minnesota . . ."

Does that mean for the immediate short term, back to office lawyering for hedge fund Varde, then keeping an aim and intent for more political adventure? Or does it mean lesson learned, politics is for others, I'm going to private practice again, but keeping a mood while staying in private practice? 

I'd surely like the latter, but suspect the former. 

Prior crabgrass posting voiced a guess: Schultz seeking a judgeship - some court, some level, perhaps starting at the top as in seeking the AG seat; shooting for a seat on the Minnesota Supreme Court, where Alan Page's name recognition carried such an effort earlier. 

With Walz being governor meaning there will be no appointment into a vacancy, so instead think of his running against an incumbent soon enough that the AG run name recognition will still hold weight - at whatever judicial level strikes his fancy. 

Judicial elections being how they are.

Timmer

Steve's post, today, "The incredible lightness of being Jim Schultz," starting -

I wrote an email to a not-lawyer friend about the unsuccessful Republican candidate for attorney general, Jim Schultz. Since Minnesota has probably not – regrettably – heard the last of Schultz, I thought, on reflection, that my remarks were worth summarizing and repeating here. They are intended for our collective memory when Schultz resurfaces.

I’ve known many lawyers like Jim Schultz over the years: smarmy, smug, and supercilious, but at their root insecure and thin-skinned. Wan and apparently physically wasted, and with sweaty palms, they inhabit the warrens of Big Law as office lawyers everywhere. They are poor candidates for politics or public office.

I sound dismissive of the type. That’s because I am.

And ending -

 I understand that purring Republican sycophant Andy Brehm (shown above with Schultz) thinks that Jim Schultz would be a good candidate to run against Amy Klobuchar in two years. Seriously, I think this is a really bad idea for Republicans; Amy Klobuchar would tear off Jimmy’s limbs one by one and eat them. She made Brett Kavanaugh wail in anguish, and whatever you think of Brett Kavanaugh, he’s a much more formidable character than Jimmy.

I hope you will keep these thoughts in mind when Jim Schultz comes around again, or if you don’t, that Google will.

Steve wrote more, and the above title/link allows readers to enjoy the full thinking.

However, start and finish, this is a person who will resurface and want to touch politics again, so we should not let who Schultz is and has been escape notice from having too short a media/voter attention span.

Campaign violation complaint

Sahan Journal, Oct. 28 reporting, "Minnesota faith leaders denounce ‘race-baiting’ in GOP ads for attorney general campaign," with the subheadline, 

Interfaith leaders called on Republican attorney general candidate Jim Schultz to “rebuke and demand” that the ads be taken down. The Minnesota DFL has questioned whether Schultz worked with an independent political fund to place the ads.

This item is extremely well written and clear in everything it reports. Crabgrass readers are urged to read it in its entirety,  and to rotor over to the full online copy of the DFL's campaign violation filing. That filing copy includes exhibits, and is self explanatory. Either the CFB will show real teeth, prove wholly feckless; or land in between.

Others may know whether the CFB in investigatory mode can subpoena witnesses to testify under oath. If so, that earlier concession statement of Schultz does name several names, arguably jointly and severally liable with the candidate himself, who is ultimately responsible for actions of his campaign. Or there might be a consistent stonewall display of "non-coordination" which the CFB might conveniently buy into. 

Hopefully media coverage of the CFB handling of the complaint will not be sucked into a black hole of nothingness, as the campaigns and election this November recede into ever more distant past.

LAST: This blog, and Timmer this cycle have both been critical of Schultz and his Fearless Fosdick crime doesn't pay unimaginative and shallow campaign, as well as his appalling inexperience for the office. Crabgrass, moreover, has been disappointed that such a low-road campaign had any traction, much less making it a close race. With Schultz publishing that late polling even favored him over Ellison.

Here, that disappointment has been the motive of the AG campaign gaining more focus than any other contest this cycle. Wardlow's campaign last cycle against Ellison had a similar coverage motivation at Crabgrass. Each campaign trotted out 'police endorsed' as something special, Wardlow having Bob Kroll aboard last cycle to make it even more vexingly stupid.