Developers are Crabgrass : Ugly draftmanship of a proposed Constitutional Amendment.

Saturday, May 18, 2024

Ugly draftmanship of a proposed Constitutional Amendment.

SCREEN CAPTURE: Homepage, a Minnesota organization, https://eramn.org/

click image to enlarge and read

That page endorses a particular draft amendment to Minnesota's Constitution, per

https://eramn.org/2023-minnesota-state-era-bill/ -

ERA Minnesota worked with legislators to draft a bill to present to the Minnesota House and Minnesota Senate in the 2023 – 2024 legislative session.
Following the success of Nevada’s Universal Equal Rights Amendment, we adopted similar language to help truly ensure legal equality—with no qualifiers.

2024 PROPOSED Robust ERA Language for SF37:

All persons shall be guaranteed equal rights under the laws of this state. The state shall not discriminate against any person in intent or effect on account

of race, color, national origin, ancestry, disability, or sex, including but not limited to pregnancy, pregnancy outcomes and reproductive freedom, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.

Italics are preface, plain text is bill text - why the paragraph is formatted chopped up is unclear, but it's their page to format.

First problem, non-citizens are persons and a national debate exists on whether a fetus or embryo is a person and this THING begs the question entirely.

Children are persons, so should they vote? Incarcerated felons are persons. What meaning does "equal protection" then have? That right to life thing about fetuses is an important abortion question. Can the fetal right to a "pregnancy outcome" without any "interference" be honored along with a woman's desire to abort?

Now, an unwanted pregnancy, the condom tears or a gentleman is assured a sex partner is practicing contraception when she is not (both do happen); so that gentleman is a "person," who may not want ongoing financial responsibility for a child, pregnant woman wanting no abortion - vs agrees to an abortion.

Three pregnancy outcomes come to mind - abortion before full term, full term with adoption, full term, woman not wanting to put child up for adoption.

Men who impregnate would be treated unequally if the woman impregnated wants to keep the born child, relatively to treatment of those equally positioned men but where the impregnated woman picks one of the two other options - So inequality, unless a woman wanting a full term also assumes full financial responsibility for her choosing with the man having no voice in choice.

That's not equality among men facing different outcomes of pregnancy, quite clearly so. The woman does have the thing in her body, but the man "put" it there, so what is equal choice?

There is a gap in things; the controversy of pre-delivery personhood being the biggest gap, the unequal treatment of two men, given the whim of two women thing is another. Clearly current law in general says fetus not equal to "person." In general. And men responsible for causing a pregnancy currently are disallowed any remedy about abort/ adopt/ finance. But this proposal is a change in the very fabric of the Constitution, if put to a popular vote and adopted, a change in law in its most fundamental embodiment.

It's not thought out, and, moreover ageism is not barred by this "Equal Rights Amendment."

People should think before they shoot a loaded, cocked gun.

___________UPDATE____________

Now, with this proposal and while the nation has a fully volunteer standing Army, the question of conscription in the future should be thought over. With pregnancy and pregnancy outcome being non factors for inequality, women, pregnant or not, should be equally at risk of being drafted out of graduate school as men. It's only fair, to be equal. With women having roles in service decided, draft equality seems a part of the "Amendment" being proposed. Along with men and women having an "equal" right to terminate a pregnancy one or the other does not want. Along with is a fetus a person. Going to the polls with some mess short of having thought things out seems - hard to phrase it otherwise - dumb.

A sentence - Assertion an embryo or fetus is a person fails as compelling state interest in determining any outcome of a pregnancy.

That would clean up one difficulty. As would the sentence - Pregnant women choosing against adoption or abortion when the impregnating man wants no financial burden of child rearing, will in such situation be singly responsible for financing the imposing of their sole decision; should they do so.

With mandated equality in the job market, unlike old days, there is cause to not hold men responsible for a pregnancy where it takes two to tango, but only one gets a pregnancy outcome choice. People being equal either is true, or not, but fictions and traditions seem swept up when it comes to "EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT" ENACTMENT.

So, THINK.

___________FURTHER UPDATE__________

Multiple bill drafts exist; see this link. What comes out of a conference committee, if things get there for a 2024 ballot question, is unknown until it emerges. But merging the traditional ERA thinking with attention to presently marginalized subgroups besides traditional male, pronouns he, his, him; and traditional female, pronouns she, her, and her; and running abortion language in too, seems a stretch. Especially where loose language where traditionally "citizen" and "person" had limited overlap, citizens having the more favorable universal status. Since we elected them, our legislators know best, and we await the process yielding an objection free measure pleasing to everyone.

From Women's March - 10-2-2021 - imagery speaks

Image is cropped from one of a series of Buzzfeed images. Click the image to access the Buzzfeed coverage of that march. This was a major event in Washington, D.C., and it happened mid-way after Trump had been fired by voters in the 2020 election, and before the one approaching. To assert as MN GOP politicians have that abortion is not an issue is an insensitive fiction concocted in some smoke filled GOP backroom. Do not let a GOP intent to deceive misleed your vote. The issue IS ON THE BALLOT. Women deserve dominion over their bodies, we all deserve privacy in our lifetime decision making.

Cracker fear and loathing toward Critical Race Theory has its precedent.

The precedent - Integration dodging intent behind segregated "non-profit" private schools, after the Brown decision was issued. Leading a twisted mind, Paul Weyrich, to issue-monger.

Politico in 2014 posted the true history of the ginned up propagandized opposition to abortion among the nation's hordes of Evangelicals as the "Weyrich solution" to energize the base. Leading to grave mischief. Evangel-Jesus-jockeys, with fellow travelers, (many of whom are surveyed as not as worked up about Roe as Alito would want you to falsely believe). Some, "foaming-at-the-mouth" rabid, however -

This is for you, Gipper and crowd.

Click that Wikipedia image, get THE STORY (and a link to the enlarged image, copyright info and all). GET: Online info leading into a new year via some pre-1947 new "old thoughts." New to many first time voters - this cycle. Not the thoughts, but the history. A history not to be found in Gipper speech transcripts, nor the Gipper's presidential library papers. Hello, Joe, Dem Party history, so pay attention. Pre-Clinton, Pre-Obama, but Dem party new-old nostalgia. Good old ways. Show the guts to walk that talk.

War Crime - Crime Against Humanity - Today, Now.

Let's go Brandon?

Yes, it relates to a NASCAR event, NASCAR attendees making a statement. But given how fifteen bucks got disappeared, and now Build Back Inconsequentially is pending, shouldn't we all chant? Trust whoever you care to, but wouldn't you like to see trust earned? Actions speak louder than words, while inaction when action is needed speaks loudest? Truthfully so? Pharma prices if anything have gone upward since Trump left while Manchin's daughter's a part of it via her grotesque EpiPen market manipulation and price gouging (a/k/a contract, combination, conspiracy in restraint of trade to gain market segment monopolization). Who might they want to fool? Biden's Justice Department appearing to not be looking at EpiPen under antitrust criminal law? Student debt relief is an aim of many, yet Biden has made no move to be helpful. Never mind Medicare for All sidetracked - Not even cosmetic change is being made to Obama's Romneycare? Taking progressives for a buggy ride? DC redux? Money talks? A Congress of old owned lackeys? Let's go Brandon?

copyright notice -

FAIR USE: Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use." * The blog is published under fair use for commentary, critique and teaching purposes, concerning news posted on the Internet (where timliness is essential; New York Times v. Sullivan). Under NOTICE from a copyright holder of concerns, mutually agreeable adjustment is anticipated.

MYOGA - Make Yacht Owners Gain Again

A RIGHT - not a privilege - EVERYBODY'S RIGHT - no limits

JOE BIDEN DOES NOT SUPPORT MEDICARE FOR ALL. That is because Biden's billionaires want to keep every last one of the people beholden, manageable that way, willing to compromise and to worry about the next paycheck and the mortgage, rather than worrying abstractly over the grossly unfair distribution of wealth and power in our nation. Reform of that situation is needed. HOWEVER, with the Biden White House team, we must wait for HOPE and CHANGE. He owes, as a career politician now a millionaire himself, after NOT ever biting a feeding hand. We need Bernie.

Bernie ran for President. Who cares?

Bernie Sanders early 2019 crowds from before the Democratic Party oligarchs did him in, Clyburn, Bloomberg, Biden - the usual suspects. What resonated with those crowds - a candidate for justice and fairness, finally and for us all: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7DRwz0cAt0 Joe Biden could have a Lincolnian legacy, if he cuts and runs from the big donor class he has so far courted, makes his platform the heart of that speech and delivers on the promises. If there is the will, there is the way.

More meddlesome in U.S. of A. politics. More money spent over Russians? Does that compute?

click here for image source plus NYTimes coverage.

Will there be blowback? There seems to be a disproportionate sense to DC's media-mania focus. Russians seem to make better theater, while Israelis generate movement on a scale Putin could only dream of? Essays and books could be written . . . However, in 2012 Romney and Bibi preceded Donald and Vlad mischief, in attempted outsider bias of U.S. national elections. Donald never visited Vlad in Russia. Romney did visit and schmooze Bibi, in Israel. "Double standard?" Go figure.

Doug Wardlow's police pal, Bob Kroll.

POLICE ENDORSED has to have a meaning, a context, and a discernible personality. G.R.Anderson writing over a decade ago, in a CityPages item, puts in a context, Bob Kroll, further fleshed out, here. It behooves the public to know who the supporters of a politician are, (photo above), since that reflects on the politician. "Rule of Law" must have a meaning to Kroll, one which few would share. Why is Mainstream Media not asking about POLICE ENDORSED, a Wardlow tout point?

IN ADDITION: In this image, isn't it Bob Kroll standing to the right hand of friend Wardlow? Looks like him. Paired Ellison haters? Anti-Muslim cohorts? How far back does the pairing go? And how has the pairing grown over time or evolved, from what start? Is there some Dobson joinder? The press should inquire.

Douglas Gary Wardlow did not merely throw the first stone . . .

He unleashed an ADF salvo, earning his ADF paycheck. Read about it, here, here and here. Outlawyered on appeal, Wardlow now apparently has no ADF paycheck. Others for ADF are pressing on. ADF appears to be a win-or-go-home team. James Dobson's team, so walk the line. Whatever you think you want, trust me, you do not want James Dobson anywhere near our attorney general office. A Berniecrat is the other choice, and is a good choice because Bernie's policies are the only future the Democratic Party has whether they accept that or not. Aimee Stephens is as human as I am, as human as Wardlow and Dobson and Hillstrom and Pelikan, the latter two seeming to have gone silent. Ms. Stevens should not be bedeviled in this Twenty-first Century. She merely wanted to be herself, do her job, and get her share. That is what each of us wants for ourselves. Evolution of politics is overdue. Ellison got piled on; is getting piled on. Click the above image.

Sell 'em Prosperity Gospel and feed 'em beans. Some never catch on.

What is Prosperity Gospel? It is: Channeling the mind of a brick into GOP and related dogma. Read this Minnesota story. Click the image to read its fine print. (image source: Bluestem Prairie) The image shows a part of the "mind" of a 30 yr. and still-going Prosperity Gospel faithful attendee. A Dev Crabgrass post fleshes things out. Islamaphobia is but one dimension of a larger "GOP base" stupidity. Stupidity you can bank on. HINT: Follow links in items linked here. Questions will get answered. And --- There's more -

DINO NEWS: Democrats in Name Only; they exist as a problem.

a DINO with an up-top money slot

This link. Al Franken in the linked WashTimes item is quoted:
“There are a lot of Minnesotans who are Franken-Trump voters. You have to go and talk to them, and you have to listen. That’s what we need to do. We need to listen.”
Al knows the score better. Al knows Sanders-Franken voter numbers dwarf that Trump-Franken segment, as to where Al needs to pay most attention, "to listen."

Al, in no uncertain terms, should be telling Tom Perez and the beltway money-bunnies of a new fresh smell in the air. Recognizing (in kind wording) one DINO foundation-family's drift, now, into irrelevancy is far from admitting what's relevant and moving full speed to the Bernie side of the force.

Dinosaurs, DINO ways and means, must and will be extinct (can you say "Primary Joe Manchin and Clair McCaskill"). As Al in the item says; listen. Hear Bernie sounding like a giant asteroid strike upon a DINO status quo. Indeed, primary the poster DINO-bunny of artful misdirection and status quo actions, Cory Booker. Gain attention from that, successful or not. Ideally, send Cory to work with Eric Cantor on Wall Street, where his heart is.